And Then You're Dead

A JOURNAL

Life, debt, work,
and the math
that doesn't add up.

Sourced essays on the systems most people live inside without ever choosing to.

The Plate Log

License-plate readers photograph every passing car, not only wanted ones. California's auditor found 99.9 percent of the 320 million images Los Angeles police stored were of cars on no hot list, kept for years and shared with hundreds of agencies nobody had vetted.

The False Match Rate

Federal testing shows face recognition's error rates vary by algorithm and by demographic group. In Detroit, Robert Williams's lawsuit says his wrongful arrest began with a match the police treated as an identification.

The Query at the Pharmacy Counter

Every controlled-substance prescription a pharmacy fills is reported to a state database that prescribers, pharmacists and law enforcement can query. In 2017 a federal appeals court let the DEA reach Oregon's with an administrative subpoena, and a risk score scaled from 0 to 999 is now laid over many states' results.

Ninety-Three Percent

From October 2013 to August 2015, Michigan let a computer decide unemployment fraud with no person reviewing the case. A federal appeals court later recited that when more than 22,000 of its fraud findings were reviewed, 93 percent turned out not to involve fraud at all.

Sealed on Paper

Pennsylvania and Michigan now seal or set aside old criminal records by computer, without a petition. The court's copy goes dark. A background screening company's copy, bought in bulk before the seal, does not go dark on its own, and federal law leaves the cleanup to the company's procedures.

The House Has a File Too

Home insurers check a shared claims-history database before they quote you, and the report is filed by property address as well as by name. Federal law makes it a consumer report you can see for free, and Texas made it illegal to hold a question about coverage against you.

The Address She Moved To

A home address is written into public and commercial records many times over, and people-search sites sell it back to anyone who asks. New Jersey's Daniel's Law, California's Delete Act and state address-confidentiality programs are the laws written to pull it back out.

The Records That Should Have Aged Off

Federal law puts a clock on most negative records in a screening report. The clock only works if the record's dates and outcome are kept current, and in 2023 regulators said TransUnion's rental screening arm reported eviction cases with stale outcomes, sealed cases and no named source.

Name Only

Many employment background checks attach a criminal record to an applicant because the name matches, and sometimes little else. In 2021 the CFPB said in writing that matching on name alone is not a reasonable procedure under federal law.

The Other Door

Identity-theft victims have a faster statutory path than an ordinary dispute, a four-business-day block, and it is a separate door from the ordinary dispute: a different trigger, a different clock, and a different duty on the company that reported the account.

Two People, One File

A credit bureau files each new record with whoever fits best, not whoever it belongs to. In 2013 an Oregon jury heard Equifax had merged one woman with a stranger of the same name, and kept them merged until she sued.

The Segment You’re In

In 2014 the FTC compelled nine data brokers to explain themselves. None of them collected anything directly from a consumer, seven of the nine bought and sold to each other, and one held over 700 billion aggregated data elements. A decade later the FTC was banning companies from selling the record of which building your phone slept in.

See all writing →

Play

Incoming

Eight waves, one for every stage of a life, and four things standing between you and them. By the last stage, one of those things is called Time.

Begin →