And Then You're Dead

The Permanent Record / Dossier · Tenant Screening

The Records That Should Have Aged Off

The law gives most bad records an expiry date. Nobody checks that the date on the record is the right one.

Federal law bars a screening company from reporting most negative items once they are more than seven years old. That limit is a clock, and a clock is only as good as the dates and outcomes the company keeps on file. In 2023 the FTC and the CFPB alleged that TransUnion's rental screening business reported eviction cases with outcomes months or years out of date, cases that had since been sealed, and records whose real source it did not name.

And Then You're Dead · October 2026 · 9 min read

Join the discussion →
Close-up, in black and white, of the rubber date wheels of a self-inking date stamp, the months and years shown reversed on the bands
The bands of a self-inking date stamp. Whatever date is set on the wheels is the date that lands on the page, right or wrong. Photo: Zv0486, CC BY-SA 4.0, cropped, via Wikimedia Commons.

Most of what is in a tenant screening report is supposed to expire. Congress wrote that into the Fair Credit Reporting Act more than half a century ago, on the idea that a debt, a lawsuit or an arrest should not follow a person for the rest of their life. The section is 1681c(a) of title 15, and it opens with a flat prohibition: except as authorized, no consumer reporting agency may make any consumer report containing the items it then lists.

A tenant screening company is a consumer reporting agency, and the report it sells to a landlord is a consumer report. The federal complaint discussed below says so in its own heading. So the age limits apply to the report a property manager reads before deciding whether you get the apartment.

What the Clock Actually Says

The list in 1681c(a) is short and specific. Bankruptcy cases drop off ten years after the order for relief. Civil suits, civil judgments and records of arrest drop off once they antedate the report by more than seven years from the date of entry, or until the governing statute of limitations has expired, whichever is the longer period. Paid tax liens drop off seven years after payment. Accounts placed for collection or charged off drop off after seven years. And then a catch-all: any other adverse item of information antedating the report by more than seven years, other than records of convictions of crimes.

Read those clauses slowly, because the exceptions are where most people's assumptions break.

First, the seven years for a civil suit or judgment is a floor, not a ceiling. If the statute of limitations on the judgment runs longer, the longer period controls. An eviction case is a civil suit, and an eviction judgment is a civil judgment, so the same rule governs them.

Second, criminal convictions are carved out of the catch-all entirely. Federal law puts no age limit on reporting a conviction. Arrests that did not lead to a conviction are covered by the seven-year rule; convictions are not.

Third, subsection (b) switches the limits off altogether for three kinds of report: those used for a credit transaction of $150,000 or more, for life insurance with a face amount of $150,000 or more, or for a job paying $75,000 a year or more. An ordinary apartment lease is not on that list.

0
years, from date of entry, after which a civil suit or judgment generally may not be reported, unless the statute of limitations runs longer
0
years of federal age limit on reporting a criminal conviction, which the catch-all in 1681c(a)(5) expressly excludes

A Clock Needs a Date

Every one of those limits is measured from something: the date of entry, the date of payment, the date of the order for relief. The statute assumes the screening company knows that date, and knows what happened in the case after it.

That assumption carries the whole rule. A screening company does not usually go to the courthouse. It buys court data in bulk, often from another data company, and loads it into its own database. Each record is a snapshot of a case as it stood when the data was pulled. If the case later ends, is dismissed, is satisfied or is sealed, the snapshot does not change unless someone sends an update and the screening company applies it.

An age limit is a rule about time. The record it applies to is a photograph of one moment. If nobody retakes the photograph, the rule is enforced against the wrong picture.

A stale record does not have to be older than seven years to do damage. It only has to describe a case that no longer looks the way the record says. And when the age limit does arrive, it can only be applied correctly to a record whose dates and status are right.

The TransUnion Rental Screening Case

On October 12, 2023 the Federal Trade Commission and the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau filed a joint complaint in federal court in Colorado against TransUnion Rental Screening Solutions, Inc., and its parent, Trans Union LLC. The complaint described the company, which it called TURSS, as furnishing background screening reports to thousands of rental property owners, property managers, employers and other screening companies across the country. It said TURSS furnished hundreds of thousands of reports containing eviction records to clients every year.

The complaint did not allege that TURSS reported records older than seven years. Its accuracy charge was brought under a different section, 1681e(b), the duty to follow reasonable procedures to assure maximum possible accuracy. But what it described is the precondition the age limit depends on: whether the screening company's copy of a court case is current.

The complaint said TURSS had failed to follow reasonable procedures in four ways: to keep multiple entries for the same eviction case out of a report, to report a case's disposition accurately, to label its data fields accurately, and to keep sealed eviction records out. It called the failure knowing and reckless.

Outcomes That Were Months or Years Old

On dispositions, the complaint alleged that in numerous instances TURSS reports carried eviction records that did not identify a final disposition and merely showed that a case had been filed, even when a later or final disposition was available in public records. It also alleged reports that showed the wrong disposition, such as a judgment for the landlord when the case had actually been dismissed. And it said that in numerous instances the missing or incorrect update had occurred months or years before the date of the report.

The complaint traced the data. TURSS bought the information behind its eviction records from LexisNexis Risk and Information Analytics Group. It had not, the complaint said, imposed specific accuracy or completeness requirements on LexisNexis, and it quoted the contract: TURSS accepts all information "AS IS," acknowledges that LexisNexis obtains its data from third-party sources "which may or may not be completely thorough and accurate," and agrees that it "shall not rely on" LexisNexis for accuracy or completeness.

The next paragraph is the one that matters most for a rule built on dates. Before April 2020, the complaint alleged, TURSS's procedures allowed it to report eviction records without regard to when an update on the records was last obtained from a particular source. In other words, the system did not track how old its own information was. TURSS changed that process in April 2020, and the complaint said it did so only after receiving a Civil Investigative Demand from the FTC.

According to the complaint, until April 2020 the system reported eviction records without regard to when they had last been updated. A rule about age was being applied by a system that did not track age.

Sealed, Then Reported

The sealed-record allegations show the same problem from another side. A court that seals an eviction case has decided the public should not see it. A screening company that already copied the case before it was sealed still has it.

According to the complaint, LexisNexis provided updates that were supposed to let TURSS find and delete records that could no longer be located and so might have been sealed or restricted after they were supplied. But before November 2021, TURSS had no procedures to make sure those updates would catch all such records. Specifically, the complaint said, the updates may not have included changes to eviction cases more than one year old if the only record was a civil new filing, even if the case was later sealed. It alleged that TURSS had notice of that gap no later than June 2018.

That is the gap the age limit cannot close. The older a filing-only record was, the less likely, under that procedure, it was to be refreshed, so the record most likely to be out of date was the one the system was least likely to recheck.

One Case, Counted Twice

The complaint also described how the reports looked. TURSS's procedure had been to show each event in a case, such as a new filing, a judgment or a dismissal, as a separate entry. Before April 2021 it also interleaved the events of one case with those of another. Two eviction cases with two events each could appear on a report as four separate entries, which the complaint said made consumers' eviction histories look more extensive than they were. TURSS began grouping events by case in April 2021, again after the Civil Investigative Demand, and the complaint said it continued to provide the old version of the report to some customers.

Until at least early 2019, the complaint added, the reports carried a field labelled "Judgment Amount" that was not necessarily an amount a court had awarded.

Not Saying Where It Came From

The age limit has an enforcement mechanism of a sort: you can ask the screening company for your file, see a record that should not be there, and dispute it. Section 1681g(a) requires the company to disclose, on request, all the information in your file and the sources of that information.

The complaint alleged that before June 2021, when consumers asked TURSS for their files, it named the court jurisdiction as the only source of a criminal or eviction record even when it had actually bought the record from a third-party vendor. A consumer looking for the place where a stale record lived was pointed to the courthouse, where the case might already show as dismissed or sealed, rather than to the company that still had the old copy. TURSS began naming LexisNexis as a source for eviction records in June 2021 and third-party criminal data vendors in June 2022, and the complaint said it did both only after the Civil Investigative Demand.

0
million dollars in consumer redress required by the October 2023 order
0
million dollars in civil money penalty paid to the CFPB under the same order

The Order

The complaint said TURSS had received tens of thousands of consumer disputes about its eviction records over the period. It listed the harms that follow from an inaccurate tenant screening report: prolonged housing searches, extra application fees, time and money spent correcting errors, higher rent, temporary housing costs, and denial of housing.

The case was filed together with a stipulated order, which the court entered on October 18, 2023. TransUnion did not go to trial. The order required $11 million in consumer redress and a $4 million civil penalty. It also required TURSS to adopt written procedures designed to keep out of its background screening reports any sealed record, any eviction record that does not have a final outcome, multiple filings for the same case, any filing other than the most recent one showing the outcome or a superseding post-judgment filing such as a satisfaction, and any money amount other than a final judgment or a satisfaction of it. And it required the company to disclose, on request, every source of the information in a consumer's file, including the vendors it buys criminal and eviction records from.

Read against 1681c(a), that list is instructive. The statute sets an expiry date. The order had to tell a large screening company to stop reporting cases without an outcome, to stop counting one case twice, and to stop reporting sealed cases, because those were the conditions under which the expiry date was supposed to operate.

What the Statute Does Not Do

The obsolescence rule is passive. It says what may not appear in a report. It does not tell a screening company how often to refresh a court record, does not say that a record with no recorded outcome must be treated as stale, and leaves the starting date to whatever the company has on file. An applicant cannot see the database the report was drawn from, only the report and, on request, the file disclosure, which in the TURSS case did not name the vendor.

So a person whose eviction case ended in a dismissal years ago depends on a chain of updates, from the court to a data vendor to a screening company, for the old filing either to show its real outcome or, once it is old enough, to disappear. Each link in that chain can break without anyone noticing, because no one is paid to notice.

And Then You're Dead

Congress gave most bad records an expiry date, and that sounds like protection. But the date is read off a copy of a court case that a screening company bought from a vendor who sold it "AS IS," and the rule can only be as current as that copy. In the one large case regulators brought, they said the company reported outcomes months or years out of date, kept cases a court had sealed, and told people the record came from the courthouse when it came from a vendor. The law says the record expires. In practice it expires when the company's copy of it is updated.

That's it. That's the whole thing.

Comments

Loading…

Comments are anonymous and moderated.

Sources