The Permanent Record / Dossier · Insurance Scoring
The House Has a File Too
You think of your insurance history as yours. The industry also keeps it under the street address, and the address does not move out when you do.
Before a home insurer quotes a policy, it can check a shared database of past claims called C.L.U.E. State insurance departments describe a report that lists losses by date, type and amount paid, and for homeowners coverage, by property address. Federal law treats it as a consumer report, which means you can see it free once a year and dispute what is wrong. Texas went further and made it illegal to decline, cancel or non-renew a policy because a customer called to ask a question.
Join the discussion →
Most people know there is a file on them at the credit bureaus. Fewer know that when they shop for homeowners insurance, the insurer may also be reading a file about the house. It is a list of the losses that were reported against the policy, the person and the address, collected from insurers and handed back to insurers when the next application comes in.
The best-known version is called C.L.U.E., the Comprehensive Loss Underwriting Exchange. Utah's insurance department describes it in one line: a claims history database, created by ChoicePoint, which is now part of LexisNexis. Insurers use it, the department says, to check a consumer's loss history when they underwrite or rate a policy. In plain terms, it is how a company you have never done business with finds out about the pipe that burst in the kitchen three years ago, under a different insurer.
It Is a Consumer Report, Not a Courtesy
The first thing to understand about C.L.U.E. is what the law calls it. The Fair Credit Reporting Act defines a consumer report, in section 1681a(d)(1), as any communication by a consumer reporting agency bearing on a consumer's credit worthiness, character, general reputation, personal characteristics or mode of living, which is used or expected to be used as a factor in establishing the consumer's eligibility for credit or insurance to be used primarily for personal, family, or household purposes.
Insurance is in the definition by name. A report used to decide whether you get a homeowners policy, and at what price, is a consumer report, and the company that compiles it is a consumer reporting agency with the same core duties as Equifax, Experian and TransUnion.
The statute goes one step further. Section 1681a(x) creates a category called the nationwide specialty consumer reporting agency: an agency that compiles and maintains files on consumers on a nationwide basis relating to one of five things. Medical records or payments. Residential or tenant history. Check writing history. Employment history. And, fifth on the list, insurance claims.
Congress did not have to guess whether claims databases existed. It wrote them into the definition, as one of five kinds of file important enough to name.
The Consumer Financial Protection Bureau keeps a public list of consumer reporting companies, sorted by what they cover. Under the heading for personal property insurance, the first page of that list names LexisNexis C.L.U.E. & Telematics OnDemand and a second company, Insurance Information Exchange, or iiX. The bureau's own instruction for the category is short: fact-check your specialty insurance report when applying for or renewing insurance.
What the File Holds
The company does not publish a full field list on its general consumer page; that page describes a different product, its Consumer Disclosure Report, built from property records, liens, judgments and bankruptcies. The clearest public descriptions of C.L.U.E. itself come from the state regulators who field complaints about it.
Connecticut's Insurance Department says the report includes policy information such as name, date of birth and policy number, and claim details: the date of loss, the type of loss and the amounts paid. It says only policy information, including loss history, is stored, and that the database does not hold credit reports, criminal records or lawsuits. Utah's department gives the same list.
And then the line that gives this piece its title. For homeowners coverage, Connecticut says, the report includes the property address. For auto coverage it lists the vehicle. Consumers, the department adds, can access C.L.U.E. reports on themselves and on their own properties.
Five Years or Seven
How far back the file reaches depends on which regulator you ask. Connecticut's department says the database contains up to seven years of personal property claims history. Utah's says up to five. Both pages are current consumer guidance from state agencies, and they do not agree. This page does not try to settle it; the honest answer is that the window is at least five years and may be seven, and the only way to know what is in yours is to pull it.
Either number is long next to the life of a policy. A homeowners policy renews every year. A loss can follow a household through five or more of those renewals, and through a change of insurer, because the new company reads the same shared file the old one wrote into.
The Address Stays Behind
Credit files are organized around people. The property side of a claims database is organized around people and places at once, and that is what makes it unusual. When a homeowners report is tied to an address, the address carries its own history of water, wind, fire and theft, and the address does not change hands the way a person's name does.
Utah's department sets out who may see a property's report: C.L.U.E. reports, it says, can only be accessed by the owner, the insurer or the lender for the property. Read that list from the other direction. A buyer looking at a house is none of the three. Until closing, the people entitled to the property's loss history are the seller, the seller's insurer and the seller's lender.
You can inspect the roof, the foundation and the wiring before you buy. The record of what already went wrong under that roof belongs to someone else until the deed is yours.
The regulators' pages do not say exactly how an insurer weighs a prior owner's claims when it quotes a new owner, and this piece does not claim to know. What they do establish is narrower and enough: the report for a home includes the address, and access to it is limited to the people already attached to the property.
A Question Is Not a Claim, Mostly
The part of this system that frightens people is the phone call. You notice a stain on the ceiling. You call your agent to ask whether that kind of thing is covered. Did you just file a claim?
The state regulators' answer is careful. Both Connecticut and Utah say C.L.U.E. has instructed insurers not to report inquiries about possible coverage. Both also say the opposite risk is real: if you discuss an actual loss with your insurer, that may be recorded as a claim even if no payment is made. Utah's page tells consumers to say clearly whether they are filing a claim or only asking a question.
That is guidance, not law, and it rests on an instruction from the database to the companies that feed it. One state turned it into a statute. Texas Insurance Code section 551.113 applies to standard fire, homeowners, and farm and ranch owners policies, and to personal auto. Subsection (b) says an insurer may not consider a customer inquiry as a basis for declination. Subsection (b-1) says an insurer may not consider a customer inquiry as a basis for nonrenewal or cancellation.
The definition does the real work. A customer inquiry, under subsection (c), is a telephone call or other communication made to an insurer that does not result in an investigation or claim and that concerns the general terms of the policy or coverage. It includes asking how to file a claim and asking whether a policy covers a loss, unless the question is about specific damage that then leads to an investigation or claim.
The Legislature added the section in 2005, by H.B. 363, effective September 1 of that year, and amended it twice more, in 2013 and 2015. A protection does not usually need to be written, and then rewritten, unless the thing it forbids was happening often enough to matter. This page could not find, and does not state, a documented case of a Texas insurer doing it.
Claims Are Counted Anyway
Texas law does not pretend real claims are free. The neighboring section, 551.107, lets an insurer refuse to renew a standard fire, homeowners, or farm and ranch owners policy if the insured has filed three or more claims under it in any three-year period, so long as the insurer warned the insured in writing after the second. Without that warning, it may not refuse renewal on claims. The same section lets an insurer add a surcharge at renewal when the insured filed two or more claims in the preceding three policy years.
Put the two sections side by side and the shape is plain. Asking is protected. Reporting damage is a claim, whether or not anything is paid, and claims are counted against a three-year window that the shared database keeps for five or seven. The line between the two runs through a single conversation, and the person who decides which side of it you were on is the one taking notes at the insurer.
What You Can See
Because the report is a consumer report, the federal rights that come with a credit report come with this one too. Section 1681g says a consumer reporting agency shall, upon request, clearly and accurately disclose to the consumer all information in the consumer's file at the time of the request. It must disclose the sources of the information. And it must identify each person that procured a report on you, for most purposes during the one-year period before your request.
That last item matters for insurance. It means you can find out which insurers pulled your claims history in the past year, including ones that quoted you and ones you never heard back from.
Section 1681j makes the first copy each year free. A nationwide specialty consumer reporting agency must make the disclosures once during any 12-month period without charge on request, and the agency must set up a streamlined process for consumers to ask, including, at minimum, a toll-free telephone number. Connecticut's department lists a LexisNexis number for requesting your C.L.U.E. report and its website for personal reports.
What You Can Fix
Both state departments describe the same dispute path. If you find an error, you contact LexisNexis directly and report the problem. LexisNexis asks the insurer that furnished the entry to verify it. Utah says the insurer has 30 days to respond with evidence that the information is accurate, and that if it does not respond in that time, LexisNexis removes the information. Connecticut adds that you will be told the result within 30 days, and that you can add a personal statement explaining an item, which is then included on future reports.
That statement is worth knowing about when the fact is accurate but misleading: the water claim that was opened and closed with nothing paid, or the loss that happened before you bought the house. The entry stays. The explanation travels with it.
And Then You're Dead
Your house has a file, and so do you, and the database that holds them was built by the industry that reads them. The law does three useful things about it. It names insurance claims as one of the five kinds of specialty file, so the full set of FCRA rights applies. It gives you one free copy a year and a list of who looked. And in Texas, at least, it forbids an insurer from turning a question into a reason to drop you. It does not tell you what the house did before it was yours, and it does not stop a careful phone call about a real stain from becoming a line on a report that outlasts the policy. Pull the report before you buy, before you renew and before you call. That's the only file in this story you can read on your own schedule.
That's it. That's the whole thing.
Sources
- The definition of a consumer report, including eligibility for insurance for personal, family, or household purposes — 15 U.S.C. § 1681a(d)(1); the five kinds of nationwide specialty consumer reporting agency, including insurance claims — 15 U.S.C. § 1681a(x) (Legal Information Institute, Cornell Law School)
- Disclosure of all information in the file, its sources, and each person who procured a report in the preceding year — 15 U.S.C. § 1681g(a)(1)–(3); free annual disclosure and the streamlined request process with a toll-free number for nationwide specialty agencies — 15 U.S.C. § 1681j(a)(1)
- The personal property insurance category, listing LexisNexis C.L.U.E. & Telematics OnDemand and Insurance Information Exchange (iiX) — Consumer Financial Protection Bureau, List of consumer reporting companies
- What C.L.U.E. is and who created it; the five-year history; what is stored; who may access a property's report; the instruction not to report coverage inquiries; the 30-day dispute response and removal — Utah Insurance Department, C.L.U.E.
- The seven-year history; policy and claim fields; the property address on homeowners reports; inquiries versus discussed losses; the request number and website; the dispute process and personal statement — Connecticut Insurance Department, C.L.U.E. FAQs
- LexisNexis's description of its general Consumer Disclosure Report (company's own description) — LexisNexis Risk Solutions Consumer Portal
- Customer inquiries may not be a basis for declination, nonrenewal or cancellation; the definition of customer inquiry; enactment by H.B. 363 (2005) and amendments in 2013 and 2015 — Texas Insurance Code § 551.113; refusal to renew after three claims in three years with notice, and the two-claim surcharge — Texas Insurance Code § 551.107 (Texas Constitution and Statutes, Chapter 551)
- Photo: "FEMA - 39186 - FEMA house inspector in the field in Texas", Shoreacres, Texas, October 8, 2008, Greg Henshall / FEMA, public domain, via Wikimedia Commons
Comments
Loading…