And Then You're Dead

The Permanent Record / Dossier · Criminal Records & Justice Data

Sealed on Paper

The court sealed your old case without you ever asking. The company that copied the court's files years ago was not part of that order.

Pennsylvania and Michigan have both written laws that seal or set aside eligible criminal records by computer, in batches, with no petition and no lawyer. The court's copy goes dark. But a background screening company that bought a bulk copy of the court's data before the seal still has its own copy, and nothing in the state law reaches inside its database. What happens to that copy depends on the company's procedures, which federal law requires to be reasonable and does not otherwise spell out.

And Then You're Dead · October 2026 · 9 min read

Join the discussion →
The back of a pale green envelope closed with five large red wax seals, one at each corner and one at the centre where the flaps meet, with a round black Copenhagen postmark below the middle seal
The reverse of a Dutch insured money letter, 1932, closed with five wax seals of De Twentsche Bank at Stadskanaal and postmarked on arrival in Copenhagen. A seal tells you the envelope has not been opened. It says nothing about who read the letter first. Photo: Post of the Netherlands, public domain, via Wikimedia Commons.

For most of American history, getting an old criminal case sealed worked like any other court proceeding. You found out you were eligible, which was its own research project. You found the forms. You filed a petition, sometimes paid a fee, sometimes waited for a hearing, and a judge signed an order. Then the court restricted the record. Most people who qualified never started. The ones who did were mostly the ones who could afford a lawyer or found a legal aid clinic.

Clean slate laws take the person out of that sequence. The state's own computers find the eligible records, and the courts seal them in batches. You do not file anything. You may not even know it happened.

That is a real change, and it is the first half of this story. The second half is about a different set of computers, the ones that belong to companies that buy court data in bulk and sell it to employers and landlords. Those computers were not named in the statute. They kept their copies.

The First Law to Seal by Machine

Pennsylvania went first. Act 56 of 2018, which began as House Bill 1419, was approved by Governor Tom Wolf on June 28, 2018. It amended the state's Criminal History Record Information Act and added a new section, 18 Pa.C.S. § 9122.2, titled "Clean slate limited access." Pennsylvania calls the result limited access rather than sealing, but the mechanism is the one the rest of the country now copies: the record stays in government hands for law enforcement and a list of other uses, and disappears from public view.

Section 9122.2 sorts records into three groups that qualify automatically. The first is a conviction for a second- or third-degree misdemeanor, or a misdemeanor punishable by no more than two years, once the person has gone ten years without a conviction for any offense punishable by a year or more and has paid every court-ordered financial obligation of the sentence. The second is any charge that ended in something other than a conviction: an acquittal, a dismissal, a withdrawn charge. The third is a summary offense, ten years after the judgment and once the fines are paid.

Then the law describes the machine. On a monthly basis, the Administrative Office of Pennsylvania Courts sends the Pennsylvania State Police central repository the records of convictions that appear eligible. Non-conviction dispositions and summary convictions go over within 30 days of becoming eligible. The State Police run a validation against their own data and have 30 days to send back any record that is ineligible or does not match. When the 30 days pass, the courts drop the rejected records, and each county court of common pleas issues, monthly, an order for limited access covering every remaining record in its district.

No petition, no hearing, no lawyer. A list goes out each month, comes back with the mismatches removed, and a court signs one order for everything left on it.

The law also had to deal with the people who were already eligible on the day it took effect, years of records at once. For them it set a deadline instead of a monthly cycle: the State Police and the AOPC were to identify and finish processing every record already eligible within 365 days of the effective date. Most of the act itself took effect 365 days after it was signed. That is what a backlog looks like when it is written into a statute. Implementation is not instant, even when the law is automatic. It takes a year to catch up, and then it runs on a monthly clock.

Michigan's Version Runs Daily

Michigan's Clean Slate package was signed on October 13, 2020, as a group of bills that includes Public Act 193 of 2020, effective April 11, 2021. The bills widened the paper application process for setting aside convictions. They also created a process to set aside certain convictions automatically, without an application.

The automatic part took longer. According to the Michigan State Police, the new process required technical changes to the state's Criminal History Record database, and the legislation allowed two years of development for them, so automatic set-asides began on April 11, 2023. The State Police describe the waiting periods on their clean slate page: seven years for misdemeanors, and ten years for felonies, measured from sentencing or from release from state prison, whichever is later. There are limits on how many convictions qualify and a list of offenses that never do, and nothing happens if a criminal charge is pending.

The notice step is also automated. Beginning April 11, 2023, the State Police said, they would notify the courts daily, sending each a file by secure transfer of every eligible conviction set aside in the state database.

0
days Pennsylvania's Act 56 gave the State Police and the courts to process every record already eligible when the law took effect
0
days the Pennsylvania State Police have to send back a record as ineligible or a non-match before the monthly court order issues
0
years of development Michigan's legislature allowed before automatic set-asides began on April 11, 2023

What the Order Reaches

Read the Pennsylvania law for whom it binds. After a limited-access order, a criminal history record is available to a noncriminal justice agency only under the exceptions in the statute. Act 56 amended § 9121 to say that a court or the AOPC may not disseminate to an individual, a noncriminal justice agency, or an Internet website any information that is the subject of a limited-access order.

That sentence binds the court and the courts' administrative office. It governs what they will release from the moment the order is signed. It cannot reach a record the court already released.

And courts did release them, routinely, in bulk. Pennsylvania's court administrators distribute criminal case data in bulk to subscribers, as the CFPB itself noted in 2024, and background screening companies are the obvious customers. A company that receives a bulk copy keeps a database of its own. When an employer orders a report, the company can answer from that database instead of sending someone to the courthouse.

So on the day a monthly order seals a decade-old misdemeanor, there are at least two copies of the record. The court's goes dark. The private copy is exactly as it was the day before, and it stays that way until the company does something about it.

The seal closes the court's envelope. It does nothing about the copies made while the envelope was open.

What Federal Law Asks of the Copy

A background screening company that sells reports to employers or landlords is a consumer reporting agency under the Fair Credit Reporting Act, and the act's accuracy rule applies to it in full. Section 1681e(b) requires every consumer reporting agency preparing a report to follow reasonable procedures to assure maximum possible accuracy of the information concerning the individual about whom the report relates.

For employment reports there is a second, older rule aimed at exactly this situation. Under section 1681k(a), an agency that compiles public record information likely to hurt someone's chances of getting a job must do one of two things. It can notify the consumer, at the time it reports the record to the employer, that public record information is being reported, with the name and address of the employer. Or it can maintain strict procedures designed to ensure that whenever such information is reported, it is complete and up to date.

The statute then says what "up to date" means for court records: items of public record relating to arrests, indictments, convictions, suits, tax liens, and outstanding judgments are considered up to date if the current public record status of the item at the time of the report is reported.

Notice the word current, and notice the alternative. A company that chooses the notice route has not promised that its copy is current. It has promised to tell you that it reported something. You then learn about the sealed misdemeanor at the same moment your prospective employer does.

The CFPB's Answer

On January 23, 2024, the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau issued an advisory opinion on background screening that addressed sealed records directly. Its conclusion was that a consumer reporting agency reporting public record information is not using reasonable procedures to assure maximum possible accuracy if it lacks procedures to make sure it does not report information that has been expunged, sealed, or otherwise legally restricted from public access, in a way that would prevent the user from getting it directly from the government agency that keeps the records.

The Bureau gave its reason in one sentence. Once a conviction or other public record has been sealed or expunged in that way, the opinion says, it is misleading and inaccurate to include it as part of the person's background in a consumer report because there is no longer any public record of the matter.

It also said what such procedures might look like. They could include reporting only newly gathered information, or cross-checking existing data against updated sources so that sealed and expunged matters can be identified and removed. Some agencies, it added, may be able to request lists of expunged matters from the original source and delete them from their databases. And the opinion described Pennsylvania specifically: the AOPC, it says, regularly produces lists of expunged cases for entities that subscribe to its bulk distribution of criminal case data, and contractually requires them to use those lists to remove the cases.

The opinion added one more problem that is easy to miss. A consumer reporting agency must make sure that information it has removed does not reappear, including, in the Bureau's words, situations in which a third-party vendor resupplies information that the agency has already removed. A screener that cleans its own database and then buys another vendor's older copy has put the sealed case back.

The Cases Already on File

None of this was new when the Bureau wrote it, and the opinion said so by listing earlier enforcement. In 2015 the CFPB took action against an employment background screening company, General Information Services, alleging among other things that it failed to use reasonable procedures to keep expunged criminal records out of its reports; the consent order is dated October 29, 2015. The opinion also describes a Federal Trade Commission complaint against HireRight Solutions alleging that it failed to take reasonable steps to make sure its reports were current and reflected updates such as expungements, so that employers sometimes received reports that wrongly listed criminal convictions.

The Bureau also noted the general shape of the industry. Screening companies, it wrote, use different identifying information to search, search different databases, external and internal, apply different criteria to decide whether a record matches a person, and employ different procedures for updating information. That last phrase is the whole problem. How often a given company re-checks its copy against the court, or whether it does at all, is a business decision. The law asks whether the procedure is reasonable. It does not set a refresh interval.

Why Automation Makes the Gap Wider

Under the old petition system, a sealing order was a rare event tied to one person who had gone to some trouble. That person tended to check afterward. Some of them ordered their own background report to see what an employer would see.

Automatic sealing reverses that. It produces orders in volume, monthly in Pennsylvania and daily notices in Michigan, for people who never asked for them and may not know they exist. That is the point of the laws: relief that does not depend on knowing how to get it. But it also means the people whose records were sealed are the people least likely to know they should check whether a private database caught up.

A screener that relies on a subscription to updated data and actually uses the removal lists will drop the case. A screener that answers from an old bulk copy and refreshes it rarely will keep selling it. A screener that chose notice under section 1681k instead of strict procedures will tell you it reported the record, after it did. Nothing in either state's clean slate law can tell the difference among them. That is the federal statute's job, and the federal statute's tool is a lawsuit or a dispute after the fact.

And Then You're Dead

Clean slate laws are built on a sound idea: if the state can find eligible records by computer, it should not make people petition for relief they have already earned. Pennsylvania wrote a monthly cycle into its statute, and Michigan sends its courts a file every day. But a sealing order is an instruction to the government about the government's own copy. The copies that matter most to a job application are often the ones the government sold years earlier, sitting in a database whose owner decides how often to look again. The CFPB has said reporting a sealed record is inaccurate. The law that seals it is silent about the copy, and the person it was sealed for usually finds out when the employer calls back with a question about a case that, as far as the court is concerned, no longer exists.

That's it. That's the whole thing.

Comments

Loading…

Comments are anonymous and moderated.

Sources