The Permanent Record / Dossier · Background Checks & Hiring
Name Only
You assume a criminal background check finds your record. Often it finds a record with your name on it, which is a different thing.
Many employment background checks attach a criminal record to an applicant because the name matches, and sometimes little else. In 2021 the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau said in writing that matching on name alone is not a reasonable procedure under federal law. Six years earlier it had ordered a screening company that did not even require a middle name, and its affiliate, to pay $10.5 million back to the people they had misreported.
Join the discussion →
Run a background check on a job applicant and the report that comes back has a section for criminal history. If that section lists a conviction, the employer will read it as the applicant's conviction. It says so, in effect: here is the person you asked about, and here is what the courts have on them.
What the report usually does not say is how the screening company decided the court record and the applicant were the same person. Court records do not carry a national identification number. They carry a name, and sometimes a partial birth date or a city. Somewhere between the courthouse and the employer, a program compared those fragments to the applicant's details and decided they matched. How strict that comparison was is the whole question, and it is almost never on the page.
Three Ways to Match
There are roughly three standards a screening company can apply when it lays a court record next to an applicant. The loosest is name only: the first and last names on the record are the same as, or similar to, the applicant's, and that is enough. A step up is name plus one more identifier, usually a date of birth or an address. The strictest uses the full set, the name, full date of birth, Social Security number and address history, and refuses to report a record that cannot be tied to the applicant on more than one of them.
The CFPB set out the definition it uses in a November 2021 advisory opinion. Name-only matching, it wrote, occurs when a consumer reporting agency uses only first and last name to decide whether a particular item of information relates to a particular consumer, without using other personally identifying information such as address, date of birth, or Social Security number. The opinion's formal coverage section adds the important qualifier: names that are identical or similar, without verifying the match against anything else.
The trouble with the loose end of that range is arithmetic. The advisory opinion cited the 2010 census: more than 2.4 million people with the last name Smith, 1.9 million Johnsons, 1.6 million Williamses, and more than a million each named Brown, Jones, Garcia, Miller, Davis, Rodriguez, Martinez or Hernandez. Given those numbers, the CFPB wrote, it is not unlikely that thousands, or even tens of thousands, of consumers might share a particular first and last name. It pointed to a study that found first-and-last-name pairs such as James Smith that each belonged to more than 30,000 people, and to a federal appeals court that, deciding a background-check case in 2016, called "David Smith" an exceedingly common combination "to the tune of over 125,000 individuals living in the United States."
Who Gets Matched Most
The risk is not spread evenly. Last names cluster more tightly in some groups than in others, and the advisory opinion said so directly: the risk of mismatching from name-only matching is likely to be greater for Hispanic, Asian, and Black individuals, because there is less last-name diversity in those populations than among non-Hispanic white people.
The numbers it relied on came from a Census Bureau study of the 2010 count. Just 26 last names cover a quarter of the Hispanic population. It takes 319 to cover a quarter of non-Hispanic white respondents. Of Hispanic respondents, 16.3 percent reported one of the ten most common Hispanic last names; the comparable figure for non-Hispanic white respondents was 4.5 percent. The study found similar clustering for Asian and Black respondents. The CFPB added one more estimate: more than 25,000 people in the United States each named Maria Garcia, Maria Rodriguez, Maria Hernandez or Maria Martinez.
A matching rule that is merely careless for an uncommon name becomes close to a coin toss for a common one, and the common names are not distributed at random.
None of this requires anyone to intend a disparity. A name-only rule treats every applicant the same way. It is the population of names it is applied to that is uneven.
Why the Courthouse Does Not Help
The obvious fix would be to match on the identifiers that actually distinguish people, a full date of birth and a Social Security number. Court records are where that runs into a wall, partly by design.
Federal courts redact. Under Federal Rule of Criminal Procedure 49.1, unless the court orders otherwise, a filing that contains an individual's Social Security number or birth date may include only the last four digits of the Social Security number and only the year of birth. A home address is cut to city and state. The rule took effect in December 2007, adopted under the E-Government Act of 2002, which told the Supreme Court to write rules protecting privacy and security as court documents went online.
The reason is sound. Public dockets are now searchable from anywhere, and a full birth date plus a Social Security number is most of what an identity thief needs. But the same redaction that protects the defendant removes the details that would let a screening company tell that defendant apart from an applicant with the same name. A record that says only "born 1984, last four 0000, Columbus, Ohio" narrows the field, but it does not close it. State courts set their own rules, and this entry did not find a national count of which courts redact what.
So the screening company is left with a choice. It can go back to the source, a clerk's index, an order with fuller identifiers, another database, and do the extra work of confirming the match. Or it can report what it has and let the applicant sort it out.
The Duty the Statute Wrote for Employment Reports
The Fair Credit Reporting Act has a general accuracy rule for every consumer report. Section 1681e(b) requires a consumer reporting agency to follow reasonable procedures to assure maximum possible accuracy of the information concerning the individual about whom the report relates. Background screening companies that sell reports to employers are consumer reporting agencies under the act, and that duty applies to them.
Employment reports built from public records get an additional rule of their own. Section 1681k applies when an agency furnishes a report for employment purposes and compiles items of public record that are likely to have an adverse effect on a consumer's ability to obtain employment. The agency then has two options. It can, at the time it reports the information, notify the consumer that public record information is being reported, together with the name and address of the employer receiving it. Or it can maintain strict procedures designed to insure that whenever such information is reported, it is complete and up to date.
The general rule says reasonable procedures. The employment rule, for the agency that does not send the notice, says strict ones. A name alone meets neither word.
The notice option is worth reading closely, because it shows what Congress thought the fallback was. If the agency does not want to commit to strict procedures, it must at least tell the applicant, at the time, that a record is going to the employer, so the applicant can say "that is not me" before the decision is made. The statute imagined someone being told. A report sent on a name match, with no notice and no second identifier, takes away both protections at once.
General Information Services
On October 29, 2015 the CFPB announced action against what it called two of the largest employment background screening report providers. General Information Services, headquartered in Chapin, South Carolina, and its affiliate e-Background-checks.com, headquartered in Dallas, Texas, together generated and sold more than 10 million consumer reports about job applicants each year, according to the bureau.
The bureau's findings went straight to matching. GIS did not require employers to provide applicants' middle names. Neither company had a written policy for researching consumers with common names. In the CFPB's later summary, in the 2021 advisory opinion, the company's practice of permitting but not requiring middle names for matching criminal records resulted in the reporting of mismatched criminal record information about consumers. The bureau also found that the companies failed to keep civil suits and civil judgments older than seven years from appearing in reports.
One figure from the announcement says more than the rest. Between 2010 and 2014, nearly 70 percent of the criminal history disputes consumers filed with GIS resulted in some change or correction. That number does not say 70 percent of reports were wrong; only disputed reports are in it. It says that when an applicant looked at the criminal section and objected, the objection usually held up.
The consent order required $10.5 million in restitution, which the bureau said came to approximately $1,000 per affected consumer, and a $2.5 million civil money penalty.
Not the Only One
The advisory opinion listed other cases on the same theme, and the pattern is the useful part. In 2014, a background screening company settled Federal Trade Commission allegations that it had reported, on name-only matching, whether job applicants were on the National Sex Offender Registry. In 2018 the FTC alleged that a tenant screening company required an exact match on the applicant's last name only, with a soft, non-exact match for first name, middle name and date of birth, and that it reported criminal records belonging to people other than the applicant. In 2019 the CFPB alleged that a large screening company matched public criminal records to job applicants on limited identifiers, which could be first and last name plus either date of birth or address, a practice it said created a heightened risk of false positives because two people named John Smith might share a birth date or an address.
That last case matters for what it says about "name plus one." Adding a date of birth helps. It does not make a match safe on its own, because in a population this size two people with a common name and the same birthday are not rare enough to rule out.
What the Advisory Opinion Says
The opinion was published in the Federal Register on November 10, 2021, at 86 FR 62468, and took effect the same day. It is an interpretive rule, not a new regulation. Its argument is that the accuracy duty in section 1681e(b) includes, as an integral component, that the information actually pertains to the consumer who is the subject of the report. The statute's own words, the individual about whom the report relates, carry that meaning.
Its conclusion is direct. It has been the consistent view of the bureau, the opinion says, that name-only matching is not a procedure that assures maximum possible accuracy, and that consumer reporting agencies that use it violate section 1681e(b). It adds that nothing in its analysis creates a safe harbor, and that multiple additional elements beyond names may often be required to meet the standard. It also closes the obvious workaround. If a screening company buys data from a broker or database that has nothing but names, simply including that information in a consumer's report without further steps to confirm the match, such as consulting other sources that hold additional identifiers, is not a reasonable procedure either.
The opinion also recorded why it was needed at all. Despite the enforcement actions and court decisions, it said, some consumer reporting agencies appear to still use matching practices that fall short. It cited a 2019 National Consumer Law Center report finding that some background screening companies were still relying on name-only matches.
And it reached back to the beginning. In 1968, introducing the bill that became the FCRA, Senator William Proxmire named mistaken identity as one of the varieties of inaccurate information the law was meant to address: two individuals with the same names are confused, he said, and the deserving one is denied credit because of something done by the other. The problem the 2021 opinion addressed is the one the statute was written for, fifty-three years earlier.
And Then You're Dead
A criminal record in a background report is a claim that two things are the same person: a defendant in a courthouse and an applicant at a desk. The courthouse has deliberately stripped out most of what would prove it. What remains is a name, and the name is shared, sometimes with thousands of people, more often if your family's name is one of the common ones. The law asks for reasonable procedures, and for employment reports either strict procedures or a warning in time to object. The regulator has said a name alone is not enough. The applicant who was matched on one usually learns the rule was broken the same way the GIS applicants did: after the job is gone, by disputing a record that was never theirs.
That's it. That's the whole thing.
Sources
- The definition of name-only matching; the 2010 census surname counts; the James Smith, David Smith and Maria Garcia estimates; the surname-clustering figures (26 against 319 names; 16.3 against 4.5 percent); the summaries of the 2014 FTC sex-offender-registry case, the 2018 FTC tenant-screening complaint, the 2019 CFPB complaint and the 2015 GIS order; the 2019 NCLC finding; the Proxmire statement; and the conclusions that name-only matching violates section 607(b), that there is no safe harbor, and that name-only data from brokers may not simply be included — Consumer Financial Protection Bureau, "Fair Credit Reporting; Name-Only Matching Procedures," advisory opinion, 86 Fed. Reg. 62468 (Nov. 10, 2021)
- GIS and e-Background-checks.com: headquarters, more than 10 million reports a year, no middle-name requirement, no written common-name policy, nearly 70 percent of criminal history disputes changed or corrected from 2010 to 2014, seven-year civil records, $10.5 million restitution at about $1,000 per consumer, and the $2.5 million penalty — Consumer Financial Protection Bureau, press release, Oct. 29, 2015; Consent Order, In re General Information Services, Inc., 2015-CFPB-0028
- The general accuracy duty — 15 U.S.C. § 1681e(b); the notice-or-strict-procedures rule for public record information in employment reports — 15 U.S.C. § 1681k(a) (Legal Information Institute, Cornell Law School)
- Redaction of filings to the last four digits of a Social Security number, the year of birth, and city and state, and the 2007 committee note on the E-Government Act — Federal Rule of Criminal Procedure 49.1 (Legal Information Institute, Cornell Law School)
- Photo: "Racine (Wisconsin) City Directory 1906", pages 296–297 (PDF page 150), public domain, via Wikimedia Commons
Comments
Loading…