And Then You're Dead

The Permanent Record / Dossier · Benefits & Eligibility Systems

Ninety-Three Percent

You assume a fraud accusation from the government means someone looked at your case. For two years in Michigan, nobody did.

From October 2013 to August 2015, Michigan's Unemployment Insurance Agency let a computer system called MiDAS decide whether claimants had committed fraud, and no human being took part. It sent its questions to online accounts many people had stopped checking, treated silence as a confession, and assessed four times the benefits as a penalty. When more than 22,000 of its fraud findings were reviewed, a federal appeals court later recited, 93 percent did not involve fraud at all.

And Then You're Dead · October 2026 · 9 min read

Join the discussion →
A black-and-white pressroom lined with printing presses, men in shirtsleeves stacking tall piles of freshly printed forms on long tables under hanging lamps
The Government Printing Office in Washington running unemployment census questionnaires around the clock, October 1937, three million a day. A questionnaire is how a government asks about you at scale. Photo: Harris & Ewing, Library of Congress, public domain, via Wikimedia Commons.

Unemployment insurance is supposed to be the part of the safety net that asks the fewest questions. You worked, you lost the job through no fault of your own, and the state pays a share of your old wage for a while out of a fund your employer paid into. The questions it does ask are about eligibility: how much you earned, why you left, whether you have started working again.

Getting one of those answers wrong is not, by itself, fraud. Fraud needs intent: a person who knew the truth and misstated it to collect money they were not owed. That distinction is the whole point of a fraud finding, and it is the reason the penalties attached to one are so much heavier than the penalty for a simple overpayment. Deciding intent is a judgment about a person. For almost two years, Michigan handed that judgment to software.

The System

In October 2013, according to the Sixth Circuit's account of the case, Michigan's Unemployment Insurance Agency began administering the state's unemployment benefits system through an automated program called MiDAS, the Michigan Integrated Data Automated System. The agency designed it, in the court's words, to render automated determinations of fraudulent conduct.

MiDAS did not look only at current claims. It searched the records of people who were receiving benefits and of people who had received them at any time in the six years before the program came online. It had access to records from employers, other state agencies and the federal government, and it cross-checked what those records said about each claimant against what the claimant had reported.

Two kinds of mismatch triggered it. The first was any discrepancy between what a claimant reported when applying and what an employer later submitted. MiDAS did not ask whether the employer had made the error, or whether the two sides simply disagreed in good faith about a separation or a final paycheck. The second was an income-spreading formula. MiDAS took a claimant's earnings for a fiscal quarter and averaged them across the weeks, even across weeks in which the claimant had earned nothing. If the claimant had reported zero income for any of those weeks, the averaged figure said otherwise, and MiDAS concluded that the claimant had lied.

An average is not a paycheck. A person who worked three weeks of a quarter and reported nothing for the other ten told the truth, and the formula called it fraud.

Ten Days and a Multiple-Choice Form

When MiDAS flagged someone, it did not tell them what it had found. It did not say which employer record disagreed with them, or which week, or by how much. It sent a multiple-choice questionnaire and gave the claimant ten days to answer it.

The opinion reproduces the questions. The first asked: Did you intentionally provide false information to obtain benefits you were not entitled to receive? Yes or No. The second asked why the claimant had believed they were entitled to benefits, and offered eight answers, among them: I needed the money; I reported the net dollar amount instead of the gross dollar amount paid; I did not understand how to report my earnings or separation reason; I thought my employer reported my earnings for me; Someone else filed my claim for me.

Read those choices as a claimant who had done nothing wrong. Almost every option describes a mistake, and every mistake is an admission that something was reported incorrectly. According to the complaint as the court described it, if a claimant answered any of the questions in the affirmative, or failed to respond within ten calendar days, MiDAS robo-adjudicated the fraud issue and automatically determined that the claimant had knowingly and intentionally misrepresented or concealed information to unlawfully receive benefits.

The court's next sentence is the one this entry is about. From October 2013 to August 2015, it said, MiDAS exclusively determined whether claimants engaged in fraud. No human being took part in this process.

The Mailbox Nobody Checked

The questionnaires did not arrive by post. MiDAS sent them to claimants' accounts on the Michigan Web Account Management System, the state's online portal. That would have been a reasonable channel for someone in the middle of a claim and logging in every week. It was a poor one for everyone else the system was reaching back to. MiDAS was reviewing claims as far as six years old, and many of those people had long since gone back to work and had no reason to open a dormant unemployment account. According to the opinion, MiDAS took no additional step, no email, no letter and no phone call, to tell them a questionnaire was waiting.

So the ten days ran out unseen. Silence counted as guilt. And the person accused would learn about it, if at all, from what came next.

0
calendar days a claimant had to answer a questionnaire sent to an online account, before silence was treated as an admission of fraud
0
times the benefits received or sought, assessed as a penalty on top of restitution, the maximum state law allowed
0
percent of more than 22,000 reviewed MiDAS fraud findings that, as the Sixth Circuit recited, did not actually involve fraud

Four Times the Money

A fraud finding ended the claimant's right to benefits immediately. It also triggered the penalties. Claimants were assessed restitution plus a penalty for fraudulent misrepresentation equal to four times the benefits received or sought, which the court noted was the maximum state law permitted. The agency assessed the penalty even when the claimant had never actually received the benefits. According to the opinion, many claimants were assessed between $10,000 and $50,000, and some more than $187,000.

Then came the letters, two of them. A statement letter demanded repayment of benefits, penalties and interest, and warned that nonpayment could mean interception of state and federal income tax refunds, garnishment of wages and collection through the courts. A Notice of Determination told the recipient: Your actions indicate you intentionally misled and/or concealed information to obtain benefits you were not entitled to receive. It did not say what those actions were. And the complaint alleged that the agency often failed to send the letters, or sent them to the wrong address, because it made no effort to confirm it had a current one.

The Appeal Window That Closed in the Dark

There was a way to reach a human being. A claimant could appeal a fraud determination to an administrative law judge within 30 days, and an appeal was the only point at which, in the court's words, real-life agency employees evaluated a particular instance of suspected fraud.

But a 30-day clock that starts on a notice you never saw is a clock that has already run. The complaint alleged that the vast majority of claimants did not learn about the fraud determination until the window had closed and the fines had been assessed. When they did try to appeal, agency staff told some of them they were too late, even where the claimant still had the right to appeal because notice had never been received. And the phone line that might have sorted it out was not much use. According to the Michigan Auditor General, as the opinion recounts it, the agency never answered more than 90 percent of the calls to its help line, and of the last 50,000 calls before the audit, not a single one had been answered or returned.

The only human review in the system was an appeal, and the only way to know you needed one was a notice the system often never delivered.

Collection did not wait for any of this. The agency garnished wages and intercepted federal income tax refunds without a hearing. Because MiDAS reached back six years, the court noted, this could occur long after a person had stopped collecting benefits and stopped dealing with the agency at all. For many people the first sign was a letter from the IRS saying their refund was being taken.

The Number

Then someone checked the machine's work. In the Sixth Circuit's telling, the Michigan Auditor General reviewed more than 22,000 of MiDAS's fraud determinations and found that 93 percent of them did not actually involve fraud. The court put it plainly in the next sentence: in other words, 93 percent of MiDAS's fraud adjudications were false positives.

That figure deserves the same care the system did not take. It appears in the opinion's statement of facts, which describes the plaintiffs' complaint as it stood when the defendants asked for dismissal. The court was taking the allegations as true for that purpose, not making a trial finding. Still, it is the figure a federal appeals court chose to state as the measure of the system. A system built to find intent had, by this count, found it wrongly more than nine times in ten.

The opinion adds what happened afterward. Even after the review, the agency kept using MiDAS to detect fraud. People were now involved, but the process still ran on the same algorithms, and the plaintiffs alleged that even with human involvement about half of the fraud determinations were invalid.

Cahoo v. SAS Analytics

The federal case took its name from one of the plaintiffs, Patti Jo Cahoo. According to the opinion, she was wrongly found to have committed fraud on a claim in 2014 and did not learn of it until December 2015, when a new application for benefits was denied; she was later evicted for failing to pay rent. Another plaintiff, Kristen Mendyk, had received benefits in 2009 and 2010 and was not told of her fraud determination until November 2016. It led her to file for bankruptcy. Other plaintiffs learned of theirs only when the IRS wrote to say it was seizing their refunds.

The suit was brought under 42 U.S.C. § 1983 against the vendors who helped build and run MiDAS, SAS Analytics among them, and against individual agency officials. The appeal that produced the opinion concerned the officials, who argued that qualified immunity protected them. On January 3, 2019, the Sixth Circuit affirmed in part and reversed in part. It let the procedural due process claim go forward, holding that the officials were not entitled to dismissal on that claim, and it reversed the district court on the plaintiffs' equal protection and Fourth Amendment claims.

The core of the surviving claim is the oldest idea in the due process clause: before the government takes your property, it has to tell you, and it has to give you a chance to be heard. A questionnaire sent to an abandoned inbox, a determination that does not say what you did, and an appeal window that closes before you know it opened are, as alleged, not that.

Bauserman and the $20 Million

A separate class action had been running in Michigan's own courts since 2015. In Bauserman v. Unemployment Insurance Agency, claimants sued the agency for using MiDAS, as the Attorney General's office later described it, to falsely accuse thousands of Michiganders of unemployment fraud, resulting in the wrongful seizure of their paychecks, income tax refunds and other assets without due process.

The case went to the Michigan Supreme Court twice. In April 2019, according to the Attorney General's announcement, the court held that the class action had been filed on time under the Court of Claims Act, but that only claimants who had money collected from them for the first time on or after March 9, 2015 could be in the class. That date cut out many of the earliest people MiDAS had caught. In July 2022, the court held that the plaintiffs could seek money damages from the state for violation of the Michigan Constitution.

On October 20, 2022, Attorney General Dana Nessel and the plaintiffs' firm, Pitt, McGehee, Palmer, Bonanni & Rivers, announced a $20 million settlement. The state's own release acknowledged that the 2019 ruling had reduced the number of claimants eligible for payment. On January 29, 2024, the Court of Claims gave the settlement final approval, finding it fair, reasonable and adequate, and payments were scheduled for the first quarter of that year. The plaintiffs' lawyer, Michael Pitt, said in the state's announcement that the harm had been caused by the use of algorithms instead of people to adjudicate unemployment claims. The agency's director said the lawsuit had pointed out the limitations of the agency's existing computer system.

What the Machine Was Actually Asked

It is tempting to read MiDAS as a story about a bad algorithm. The record suggests something simpler. The software did what it was configured to do. It treated a mismatch as a misstatement, an average as a weekly wage, a non-answer as a yes, and a yes to any explanation as a confession. Each of those is a policy choice about how to read ambiguous evidence, and each one was resolved against the claimant. A person reviewing the file would have had to make the same choices, and might have made them the same way. The difference is that a person has to look at a name while doing it, and can be asked afterward why.

The scale did the rest. A caseworker who wrongly accuses one claimant makes one error, and a supervisor might catch it. A rule that wrongly accuses everyone who fits a pattern makes the same error tens of thousands of times before anyone counts, and the count arrives only after the refunds have been taken.

And Then You're Dead

A fraud finding is the government's statement that it knows what was in your head. For two years in Michigan that statement was produced by a program that never met anyone, sent its one question to a mailbox nobody checked, read silence as guilt, and multiplied the bill by four. The appeal that would have put a person in front of you closed before you knew it existed. Then the state counted, and by the figure a federal court later recited, the program had been wrong ninety-three times out of a hundred. Some of those people lost their homes or went bankrupt first. The settlement came nine years after the first suit was filed, and it covered only those whose money was taken after a date the courts chose.

That's it. That's the whole thing.

Comments

Loading…

Comments are anonymous and moderated.

Sources