The Permanent Record / Dossier · Data Brokers
The Address She Moved To
You can change your locks, your phone number and your route to work. The address you sleep at is written down in too many places to change with it.
A home address is recorded by the county when you buy, by the election office when you register, and by every company you pay a bill to. People-search sites gather those copies and sell the result to anyone with a name and a few dollars. In 2020 a man used that kind of search to find a federal judge's house. The laws written since then, in New Jersey, California and Vermont, are the first serious attempts to pull an address back out of the market, and the courts are still deciding whether they are allowed to.
Join the discussion →
In 2020 a disgruntled lawyer, as the Third Circuit later described him, went to the New Jersey home of federal Judge Esther Salas. The court summarized what happened in two sentences: he had researched her home address on the internet and went there to kill her. He shot and killed her son Daniel and critically wounded her husband.
The address was not a secret the gunman had to steal. It was the kind of fact that sits in public records and commercial databases for anyone who owns a house, votes or pays a utility bill, and that a class of websites exists to assemble and sell. New Jersey's response, signed that November, was named for her son.
How Many Times Your Address Is Written Down
Think about the records that hold the place you sleep. A deed and a mortgage, filed with the county and open to inspection. A property tax bill, indexed by owner. A voter registration, which in most states requires a residential address. Car registration, a driver's license, the account with the power company, the cable company and the water department. Every package you have ever had delivered. Every warranty card, loyalty account and magazine subscription.
None of those, alone, is a dossier. A people-search site is the thing that makes them one. It buys or scrapes records from many sources, matches them on name and other details, and presents the result as a single profile: current address, past addresses, relatives, phone numbers, sometimes a map. The industry calls these businesses data brokers, and California's law defines them by the trait that matters most here. A data broker is a business that knowingly collects and sells to third parties the personal information of a consumer with whom the business does not have a direct relationship.
You never signed up with a people-search site. That is not a gap in the law. It is the definition of the business.
That missing relationship is why moving does not work the way people expect. When you move, you tell the people who need to know: the bank, your employer, the post office, the motor vehicle agency. Each of them updates its record. Each update is a new copy of the new address in a system that may sell, license or publish it. The new address enters the same pipes the old one came through, and the profile rebuilds itself around it. Nobody at the broker has to decide to find you. The matching does it.
For most people this is an irritation, a reason for more junk mail. For someone who moved to get away from a specific person, it is the whole problem. A survivor of domestic violence who leaves, a witness, a judge who has sentenced someone with a grudge: each moved, or chose an address, on the belief that the person looking for them did not know where it was. A search box that answers that question for a fee undoes the move.
The Older Fix: A Substitute Address
States saw part of this coming long before the people-search sites got big. California's Secretary of State has run Safe at Home, which it describes as a confidential address program, since 1999. Participants get a substitute mailing address for first-class, certified and registered mail, and state, county and city agencies accept it in place of a residential or other mailing address. The program is open to victims of domestic violence, sexual assault, stalking, human trafficking, child abduction and elder or dependent adult abuse, to reproductive and gender-affirming health care providers, employees, volunteers and patients, and to public entity employees and contractors who fear for their safety.
Programs like this work at the front door of government. They keep the real address out of the public records the state itself creates. What they cannot do is reach the address that was already sold, or the one a utility, a lender or a delivery service holds and passes along. A substitute address protects the next record. The broker already has the last one.
Daniel's Law
New Jersey took the other approach and went after the copies already out there. P.L.2020, chapter 125, approved on November 20, 2020, amended the state's open public records law and added new sections to its consumer statutes. As enacted, it let a judicial officer, prosecutor or law enforcement officer, or their employer with consent, make a written request to whoever had disclosed their home address or unpublished home phone number, and gave the recipient 72 hours to remove it from the internet or wherever else it was made available.
The law as it now reads, as the Third Circuit described it in 2025, is broader. Its covered persons are active or former judges, prosecutors, police officers and child-protection investigators, and the immediate family members who live with them. A covered person may send a written notice telling the recipient not to disclose or redisclose a home address or unpublished home phone number, and not to otherwise make it available. Disclose is defined to include selling, lending, giving, publishing or offering the information, or making it available in a database, even if nobody ever searches the database. A recipient that keeps disclosing more than ten business days after notice can be sued for actual damages or liquidated damages of at least $1,000 per violation, plus attorney's fees, costs and an injunction, and punitive damages for willful or reckless violations.
One more clause changed everything that came after. Covered persons may assign their rights to send notices and to sue.
Nineteen Thousand Assignments
A company called Atlas Data Privacy Corp. built a business on that clause. According to the Third Circuit, Atlas finds companies that share its subscribers' personal data and sends them notices to stop. Subscribers pay a fee and assign Atlas their claims under Daniel's Law, and if Atlas wins it shares the damages with them. About 19,000 people had subscribed.
As alleged in the complaints, many businesses did not stop sharing the subscribers' data within the window. Atlas and a group of individual plaintiffs, including police officers, sued in federal court in New Jersey. The caption of the consolidated appeal runs to more than a page of defendants. It includes people-search sites such as The People Searchers and Spy Dialer, list and marketing-data companies, voter-data organizations, a real-estate site, and a legal-research publisher. The district court docket numbers listed on the appeal run to forty cases.
The defendants conceded that the law serves compelling interests. Their argument was that it punishes speech without asking whether anyone did anything wrong.
The defendants moved to dismiss on First Amendment grounds. They argued that Daniel's Law regulates speech based on its content, an address, and so must survive strict scrutiny, and that it chills protected speech because it makes a company liable without any showing of fault. District Judge Harvey Bartle III rejected both claims and denied the motion. Applying constitutional avoidance, he read the law to require a showing of negligence for actual or liquidated damages.
The Question the Third Circuit Sent Back
The Third Circuit took an interlocutory appeal, expedited it, and heard argument on July 8, 2025. On September 2, 2025, a panel of Judges Bibas, Freeman and Chung did not rule on the Constitution. It asked the Supreme Court of New Jersey a question first.
Judge Bibas, writing for the panel, set out the difficulty plainly. The law, he wrote, forces people or companies that share home addresses and home phone numbers to stop releasing those data if a public official requests it. As the defendants conceded, it serves compelling governmental interests. Yet it raises hard constitutional questions because it restricts their speech and seems to make them liable without fault. The statute requires willful or reckless disregard for punitive damages, but does not appear to require any mental state for the rest. Whether it does could decide the case, and state precedent on statutory construction and on constitutional avoidance pointed in opposite directions. So the court certified the question of whether Daniel's Law requires any mens rea, and if so what kind, to the state's highest court.
That is where a law written after a killing now turns: not on whether judges deserve to have their addresses protected, which no one in the case disputes, but on whether a company that leaves a name and address in a database for eleven business days after a notice must have been careless, or need only have been there.
California: One Request to Every Broker
New Jersey protects a defined group of people and leaves enforcement to private suits. California went wide. Its Delete Act requires every data broker that deals in Californians' data to register with the state privacy agency each year, by January 31, and a broker that fails to register may face administrative fines and costs.
The Act's larger idea is the accessible deletion mechanism: a single verifiable request through which a consumer directs every registered data broker that holds personal information about them to delete it. The agency built it as a website called the Delete Request and Opt-out Platform, or DROP. It is free to consumers. A California resident verifies eligibility, creates a profile, and submits one request that, in the agency's words, goes to over 600 registered data brokers.
The brokers carry the work. Beginning August 1, 2026, each must access DROP at least once every 45 days and process the deletion requests waiting there, subject to limited exceptions, and pay an access fee to download the lists. The agency warns consumers that it could take up to 90 days for a request's status to update. A broker that starts trading in Californians' data after August 1 must open its DROP account before it begins.
The design answers the moving problem in a way a one-time opt-out cannot. A broker does not delete you once and forget; it must keep coming back on a cycle. Whether that keeps pace with a profile that rebuilds every time a new record arrives is a question the first year of operation will start to answer.
Vermont: The First List of Who They Are
Before any state could tell brokers to delete anything, it had to know who they were. Vermont's registry, in Title 9 of its statutes, requires a data broker to register with the Secretary of State on or before January 31 following a year in which it met the definition, pay a $100 fee, and file its name and addresses, its opt-out procedures, its credentialing practices, its count of data breaches, and its practices on minors' data where they apply. Failing to register carries a civil penalty of $50 a day, up to $10,000 a year.
Vermont has decided that is not enough. A version of the section taking effect January 1, 2027 raises the fee to $900, requires a $20,000 bond, moves the deadline to July 1 each year and to within 30 days of becoming a broker, adds disclosures on sensitive data and on sales to certain government or foreign entities, and raises the penalty to $200 a day, with $25,000 for a materially incorrect filing.
What None of Them Reach
Put the three approaches side by side and the shape of the gap appears. Address-confidentiality programs keep a protected person's address out of new government records, but only for those who qualify and enroll. Daniel's Law reaches the copies already sold, but only for a defined class of public officials and their households, and only after a notice, and its constitutionality is unsettled. California's DROP reaches every registered broker, but only for California residents, only for businesses that meet the definition and registered, and only on a cycle measured in weeks.
None of them stops a new address from being written down. The deed still gets filed. The utility still opens an account. The record still exists somewhere, and a broker that is not registered, or not in that state, or not covered, can still find it.
And Then You're Dead
The address you move to is not a secret you keep. It is a fact you are required to give out, to the county, the election office, the bank and the power company, and each copy can travel. People-search sites did not invent that fact; they only made it searchable and put a price on it. In 2020 that search ended with a judge's son shot dead at the family home in New Jersey. Six years later, the law named for him is waiting on a state court to say what a company had to know before it can be made to pay, California is asking its brokers to check a deletion list every 45 days, and Vermont is raising its registration fee. The address is still the first thing they can find.
That's it. That's the whole thing.
Sources
- The 2020 attack at Judge Salas's home; Daniel's Law's covered persons, written notice, definition of disclose, ten-business-day window, $1,000 liquidated damages, punitive damages for willful or reckless violations and assignment of claims; Atlas's business model and about 19,000 subscribers; the defendants and district court case numbers; Judge Bartle's denial of the motion to dismiss and negligence reading; argument on July 8, 2025; and the certified mens rea question — Atlas Data Privacy Corp. v. We Inform, LLC, Nos. 25-1555 et al. (3d Cir.), Petition and Order to Certify Questions of State Law, Sept. 2, 2025 (Bibas, J.); case listing on CourtListener
- P.L.2020, c.125, approved November 20, 2020: the sections amended and added, and the original written request and 72-hour removal period — New Jersey Legislature
- The Delete Act's registration deadline and fines, the data broker definition in Civ. Code § 1798.99.80(c), the accessible deletion mechanism, the 45-day access requirement from August 1, 2026, and DROP account rules for brokers — California Privacy Protection Agency, Information for Data Brokers
- How DROP works for consumers, that it is free, the over-600 registered data brokers one request reaches, and the up-to-90-day status window — CalPrivacy, Delete Request and Opt-out Platform (DROP)
- Vermont's data broker registration deadline, fee, filings and penalties, current and effective January 1, 2027 — 9 V.S.A. § 2446; definitions at 9 V.S.A. § 2430
- Safe at Home, California's confidential address program: eligibility, the substitute mailing address accepted by state, county and city agencies, and its operation since 1999 — California Secretary of State, Safe at Home
- Photo: "Mailboxes and billboard on U.S. Highway 99, California", Dorothea Lange, March 1937, Farm Security Administration, Library of Congress Prints and Photographs Division (fsa.8b31729), public domain, via Wikimedia Commons
Comments
Loading…