Journal / Essay · Labor

The Math of the Overtime Rule

Whether you get paid extra for a long week comes down to one number on your offer letter. In 2024, the federal government tried to move that number. A court moved it back.

And Then You're Dead · August 2026 · 3 min read

Federal law says most hourly workers get time-and-a-half past 40 hours a week. Whether a salaried employee gets that same protection depends almost entirely on one number: how much they're paid. Below the line, overtime is required. Above it, an employer can work someone 55 hours a week for the same salary as 40.

Where That Line Sits

The federal threshold hasn't moved in years — not because it was left alone, but because an attempt to move it didn't survive a courtroom.

$35,568 a year works out to $684 a week — a salary that, in most of the country in 2026, doesn't clear the cost of a modest one-bedroom apartment on its own, let alone support a household. Below that line, the law assumes someone still needs overtime protection. Above it, the law assumes they don't.

The Rule That Got Struck Down

The Department of Labor tried to update that line in 2024. The update didn't last five months.

The 2024 rule would have raised the threshold to $43,888, then $58,656 by 2025 — before a federal court vacated it entirely that November.

The DOL's own estimate put the rule's Year 1 impact at roughly $1.5 billion transferred from employers to workers, mostly through new overtime premiums and raises meant to keep some employees above the new line. A federal judge in Texas struck the whole rule down, ruling the agency had improperly let salary override the actual duties test Congress intended. The threshold reverted immediately to $35,568 — including the portion of the increase that had already taken effect for five months.

What "Exempt" Actually Means

Passing the salary line is necessary but not sufficient — the law also requires the job to meet a "duties test," meant to reserve the exemption for genuine executive, administrative, or professional roles.

In practice, job titles do a lot of the work that duties are supposed to do. A worker with a manager-sounding title and a salary just over $35,568 can be classified exempt and worked well past 40 hours a week with no additional pay, regardless of whether the actual job looks anything like the executive role the exemption was designed for. Misclassification along exactly this line is one of the most common wage-and-hour violations employers face — carrying up to three years of back pay plus an equal amount in liquidated damages when it's caught, which is itself a signal of how often it isn't.

And Then You're Dead

A number that was supposed to move, moved for five months, and then moved back. The court's objection was about agency authority, not about whether $35,568 is still a reasonable line for deciding who gets paid for a 55-hour week — that question never actually got answered. It just reverted to the old answer by default, and stayed there.

That's it. That's the whole thing.

Read about wage theft · or see every essay