And Then You're Dead

The Autopsy / Case File · Vehicular & Transit

The Underride Gap

A loaded semi-trailer sits high enough off the ground that a passenger car can, under the wrong circumstances, slide underneath it instead of stopping against it. When that happens, the trailer's frame rail meets the car roughly at windshield height. Federal regulators have known this for seventy-plus years. The fix for the back of the trailer is decades old. The fix for the side of it doesn't exist yet.

NHTSA's own 2024 Report to Congress estimates that 89 people a year die in side-underride crashes involving a passenger vehicle and a large truck. An independent tracker built from the same federal crash database puts the number at more than 400 a year once rear and side underride are combined. From FARS data covering 2007 through 2020, researchers cataloged at least 1,238 side-underride crashes and 1,415 fatalities. There is still no federal requirement that a semitrailer carry a guard on its side.

And Then You're Dead · September 2026 · 9 min read

Join the discussion →
A crash test showing a passenger car with its hood crumpled and windshield frame bent after striking the rear of a truck trailer during an underride guard safety evaluation
A controlled rear-impact test evaluating an underride guard's performance, conducted by Jilin University's College of Traffic Engineering. Photo by ChengH, via Wikimedia Commons (CC BY-SA 3.0).

"Underride" describes a specific, mechanically simple failure: a passenger vehicle's crumple zone and airbags are engineered to protect an occupant from an impact at bumper height, against another vehicle built roughly the same height. A tractor-trailer's frame rail sits much higher off the ground than a car's bumper. Without something bridging that gap, a car striking the back or side of a trailer doesn't crumple against it the way it would against another car — it goes underneath, and the entire front-end safety system engineered to absorb the impact never engages. The trailer's structure meets the windshield instead. Survivability in that specific failure mode is poor, and everyone who has studied the mechanism agrees it is one of the most severe collision types on the road.

Seventy Years, One End of the Trailer

Regulators have understood the underride problem since at least 1953, when the first federal standard requiring a rear guard on trucks and trailers took effect, triggered when the distance from the cargo bed to the ground exceeded 30 inches. The rule got a grim cultural nickname in 1967, after actress Jayne Mansfield died when the car she was riding in struck the rear of a tractor-trailer on a foggy Louisiana highway at night; rear underride guards have been informally called "Mansfield bars" ever since. But the nickname outpaced the regulation. Despite renewed public attention after Mansfield's death, meaningful strengthening of the rear-guard standard stalled for decades against industry pushback.

It wasn't until 1996 that NHTSA issued the modern rear-guard standards, FMVSS 223 and 224, applying to trailers manufactured after January 1998 and lowering the guard's minimum height requirement from 30 inches to 22. NHTSA upgraded the standard again in a 2022 final rule, requiring rear guards to prevent passenger-compartment intrusion in a 35-mph full-width test. The Insurance Institute for Highway Safety went further with a voluntary program: to earn its TOUGHGUARD award, a trailer's rear guard has to prevent underride in three separate crash-test configurations — full-width, 50 percent overlap, and the much harder 30 percent overlap, where the car strikes closer to a corner of the trailer — all at 35 mph with a midsize sedan. Nine North American trailer manufacturers, including all eight of the largest, have now earned TOUGHGUARD certification on at least some of their trailers. On the back of a semi, seventy years of regulatory pressure and a decade of voluntary industry testing have produced a real, measurable safety improvement.

0
side-underride deaths a year, per NHTSA's own 2024 estimate — versus 159 to 217 a year IIHS says a side-guard mandate could prevent
0
fatalities in the at least 1,238 side-underride crashes recorded in FARS data from 2007 through 2020

The Side Nobody Regulated

None of that regulatory history reaches the side of the trailer. There is no federal requirement, today, that a semitrailer or single-unit truck carry any kind of underride guard along its length — the 53 feet of flat, unguarded space between the wheels where a car can, in a crossing or sideswipe crash, slide directly underneath the cargo box. In 2017, IIHS ran a real-world test of one proposed fix: an AngelWing side guard mounted to a 53-foot semitrailer. At 40 mph, it stopped a midsize car from sliding underneath. The technology to close this specific gap has existed, demonstrated and working, for close to a decade. It has not become a requirement.

An underride advisory committee — convened under the 2021 federal infrastructure law specifically to study the problem — recommended in its findings that NHTSA go further than side guards alone: require improved rear guards meeting something like the IIHS TOUGHGUARD standard, require side guards on trailers and single-unit trucks manufactured after 1998 be retrofitted, and study front underride protection as well. NHTSA has not adopted the recommendation as a binding rule. In June 2024, the agency did deliver a mandated Report to Congress specifically on side underride protection — the clearest official acknowledgment yet that the hazard is real and measurable. But a report to Congress is not a rule, and the report's own headline number is itself part of the story.

A rear guard took Congress and two safety agencies seventy years, a dead movie star, and a voluntary industry testing program to get right. The side of the trailer — the other 53 feet of exposed, unguarded space — hasn't gotten that far.

The National Transportation Safety Board has been asking for exactly this fix for over a decade, through the formal recommendation process it uses when it believes a regulator is moving too slowly on a hazard it has investigated firsthand. In 2010, after a string of fatal crashes involving cars striking the front of jackknifed or crossing trucks, NTSB recommended NHTSA develop a performance standard for front underride protection on heavy trucks. In 2014, it went further, recommending NHTSA develop side-underride performance standards for both newly manufactured trailers over 10,000 pounds and truck tractors over 26,000 pounds. Both recommendations are still officially open. In 2020, NHTSA asked NTSB to accept its ongoing crash-avoidance research in lieu of a side-guard rule and close the file; NTSB refused, citing what it called its "concern by the slow pace of your progress." Five years and one advisory committee later, that same recommendation is still sitting open on NTSB's books, a decade and a half after it was first written.

Whose Count Do You Believe

NHTSA's June 2024 report estimated that side-underride crashes involving light passenger vehicle occupants in two-vehicle crashes kill an average of 89 people a year. That is NHTSA's own official scope-of-the-problem number, built from its own crash-reporting systems — and it's also, by a wide margin, the smallest of the credible estimates in circulation. Researchers using an alternative counting method that IIHS says more accurately captures the true scope projected that a nationwide side-guard mandate could prevent between 159 and 217 passenger-vehicle-occupant fatalities every year — roughly double to two-and-a-half times NHTSA's own baseline. Separately, using FARS data from 2007 through 2020, independent crash researchers cataloged at least 1,238 side-underride crashes producing 1,415 fatalities, an average that also runs well above NHTSA's 89-a-year figure. And a broader independent tracking effort, combining rear and side underride together rather than treating them as separate categories, puts total underride deaths at more than 400 Americans a year.

The size of that gap matters for a specific, practical reason: it's central to the cost-benefit analysis NHTSA is required to run before it can justify a new federal mandate. A rule projected to prevent 89 deaths a year clears a very different regulatory bar than one projected to prevent 400. IIHS has directly challenged NHTSA's methodology, arguing in response to the agency's own report that it "underestimates the benefits of side underride guards for trucks" — not a dispute over whether the guards work, but over how many lives NHTSA is willing to credit them with saving before deciding whether to require them.

A Fix That Already Exists

What makes underride an unusual entry in this series is that it isn't a case where medicine, science, or engineering hasn't caught up to the problem. The rear-guard side of this story proves the opposite: a well-designed guard, built to a real crash-test standard, measurably prevents the injury mechanism it's built to stop, and manufacturers are already building trailers that pass the hardest version of that test voluntarily. The side-guard side of the story is functionally the same engineering problem solved on a different axis — IIHS demonstrated a working solution in a real 40-mph crash test years ago. What's missing isn't a technical breakthrough. It's a federal requirement that closes the gap between what a rear guard has been mandated to do since the Clinton administration and what a side guard has never been mandated to do at all.

And Then You're Dead

Every semitrailer on the interstate already has a bar bolted to its back end, required by a rule seventy years old, because in 1967 the country decided a car sliding under a truck's rear end was a problem worth regulating. The same trailer's other 53 feet of exposed side has never gotten the same decision.

That's it. That's the whole thing.

Comments

Loading…

Comments are anonymous and moderated.

Sources