And Then You're Dead

The Autopsy / Case File · Maternal & Infant

The Four Causes

The headline number in maternal mortality — Black women die at multiple times the rate of white women — gets repeated so often it can start to sound like background noise, a single ratio standing in for an entire, undifferentiated category of risk. It isn't undifferentiated. When researchers broke the gap down by the specific medical cause listed on each death certificate, most of it collapsed into just four diagnoses.

CDC's most recent national vital statistics put the 2023 maternal mortality rate for non-Hispanic Black women at 50.3 per 100,000 live births, against 14.5 for non-Hispanic white women — a 3.5-fold gap, widened from roughly 2.6-fold in both 2021 and 2022, as white and Hispanic rates fell faster than Black rates over those same years. A separate national study using enhanced vital records found that gap isn't evenly distributed across every cause of maternal death. Eclampsia and preeclampsia, and postpartum cardiomyopathy, killed Black women at roughly five times the rate of white women. Obstetric embolism and hemorrhage killed Black women at 2.3 to 2.6 times the white rate. Those four causes alone, out of dozens tracked, accounted for 59 percent of the entire Black-white maternal mortality disparity.

And Then You're Dead · September 2026 · 14 min read

Join the discussion →
A row of hospital maternity nurses in early-twentieth-century uniforms holding newborns beside a row of iron cribs
A hospital maternity ward — where the specific complication that ends a pregnancy, not just the fact that a complication occurred at all, has turned out to be the more useful unit of analysis for understanding why the racial mortality gap exists. Photo: Hennepin County Library, public domain, via Wikimedia Commons / DPLA.

Maternal mortality is one of the most frequently cited racial-disparity statistics in American public health, and for good reason: the gap is large, well documented, and has persisted for decades across multiple independent data sources. But a ratio like "3.5 times higher" describes an outcome without describing a mechanism, and mechanism is what determines where an intervention — a hospital protocol, a screening requirement, a funding stream — would actually have to be aimed. Two studies, one tracking the national trend year over year and one dissecting a single two-year window cause by cause, together sketch both halves of that picture: how big the gap is right now, and which specific ways a pregnancy actually ends that are driving most of it.

Every death behind these numbers is also, by definition, coded to a pregnancy outcome — a live birth, a stillbirth, an abortion, or a death during pregnancy itself — and to a specific point in a roughly year-long window rather than a single delivery-day event. That coding structure is part of why cause-specific analysis has become the more useful lens over the last decade: a rate ratio calculated across "all pregnancy-related death" averages together a hemorrhage that killed someone within hours of delivery and a cardiomyopathy that killed someone eight months postpartum, two clinically unrelated emergencies that happen to share a vital-records category. Separating them out doesn't change how many people died. It changes which clinical teams, which protocols, and which moments in the year after a pregnancy ends actually need to be the target.

The Trend, Restated Every Year

CDC's National Center for Health Statistics publishes an annual Health E-Stat on U.S. maternal mortality, and the three most recent editions show a national rate falling sharply overall — from 32.9 deaths per 100,000 live births in 2021, largely reflecting pandemic-era excess mortality, to 22.3 in 2022 (817 deaths) and 18.6 in 2023 (669 deaths) — while the racial gap embedded inside that falling national average moved in the opposite direction. In 2021 and 2022, the maternal mortality rate for non-Hispanic Black women ran at roughly 2.6 times the rate for non-Hispanic white women. By 2023, with a national rate of 50.3 per 100,000 for Black women against 14.5 for white women, that ratio had widened to 3.5 times. The mechanism behind the widening wasn't a rising Black maternal death count in absolute terms — it was that white and Hispanic maternal mortality rates fell fast enough, as the acute pandemic-era spike in deaths receded nationally, that the underlying racial gap became proportionally larger even as the country's overall numbers looked like they were improving.

0
times higher the 2023 maternal mortality rate was for Black women (50.3 per 100,000) than white women (14.5)
0
of the entire Black-white maternal mortality disparity explained by just four specific causes of death

Where the Gap Actually Concentrates

A national study published in the American Journal of Public Health, using enhanced vital records data from 2016 and 2017 — a more granular linkage of death certificates to pregnancy checkboxes than standard vital statistics provide — went past the topline ratio to ask which specific causes of maternal death were driving it. The answer wasn't "all of them, roughly evenly." Eclampsia and preeclampsia, the hypertensive disorders of pregnancy that can progress rapidly from elevated blood pressure to seizure and organ failure, killed non-Hispanic Black women at close to five times the rate of non-Hispanic white women — the single largest cause-specific disparity the study identified. Postpartum cardiomyopathy, a form of heart failure that develops in the weeks around delivery, showed a nearly identical five-times gap. Obstetric embolism, most often a blood clot traveling to the lungs, and obstetric hemorrhage, uncontrolled bleeding during or after delivery, showed a somewhat smaller but still substantial gap, 2.3 to 2.6 times the white rate. Combined, those four causes — eclampsia/preeclampsia, cardiomyopathy, embolism, and hemorrhage — accounted for 59 percent of the total mortality disparity between Black and white mothers, out of the full range of pregnancy-related causes of death the vital records tracked.

Eclampsia and preeclampsia killed Black women at nearly five times the white rate. Combined with three other causes, that's 59 percent of the entire disparity — not spread evenly, concentrated.

The Window After Delivery

The same enhanced-vital-records approach let researchers look at timing as well as cause, and found the racial gap extends well past the delivery itself. Late maternal deaths — the category covering deaths that occur between six weeks and a full year after the end of pregnancy, as opposed to deaths during pregnancy or in the acute weeks immediately surrounding delivery — were 3.5 times more likely among Black women than white women, the same order of magnitude as the overall mortality gap. Cardiomyopathy in particular tends to present or worsen in this later window rather than resolving immediately after birth, meaning some of the same cause-specific disparity driving the topline numbers is concentrated in a period when postpartum medical follow-up has historically been thinnest — a single six-week check-up, for many mothers, standing between an early-postpartum discharge and the year-long window during which a documented share of pregnancy-related deaths, across all racial groups, actually occur.

What Doesn't Explain the Gap

The most direct way researchers in this literature have tested whether the racial disparity simply reflects a difference in underlying health status — higher rates of hypertension, cardiovascular disease, diabetes, or obesity among Black mothers before pregnancy even begins — is to compare outcomes among patients without those documented risk factors. Predisposition to those chronic conditions does account for some of the gap; hypertensive disorders and cardiovascular risk factors are more prevalent among Black women nationally, for reasons themselves rooted in decades of unequal exposure to chronic stress, environmental hazard, and health-care access. But CDC's own analysis of the pattern is explicit that this isn't the whole explanation: when researchers looked specifically at cases where those underlying medical conditions were not present, the racial disparity in outcomes persisted anyway. That finding is what has pushed research in this area toward looking harder at differences in access to care, quality of care once a patient is admitted, and how quickly warning signs — a preeclampsia symptom, a postpartum cardiomyopathy complaint, a hemorrhage that isn't controlled fast enough — get recognized and acted on once a Black patient is already in the hospital room, rather than treating the gap as a simple product of who arrives at the delivery room sicker.

Most of It Was Preventable

A separate line of CDC-funded surveillance adds a harder edge to the cause-specific breakdown above. Maternal Mortality Review Committees — state-level panels of clinicians and public health officials that review the full medical record behind each pregnancy-related death, not just the cause listed on the certificate — found that an estimated 84 percent of pregnancy-related deaths across 36 states from 2017 through 2019 were preventable, meaning the committees judged there was a reasonable chance the outcome could have been altered by one or more changes at the patient, family, provider, facility, or systems level. The same review data found six underlying causes accounted for more than three-quarters of all pregnancy-related deaths reviewed — mental health conditions, hemorrhage, cardiac and coronary conditions, infection, thrombotic embolism, and cardiomyopathy, largely the same causes the enhanced-vital-records study above found driving the racial disparity specifically. And the leading cause varied meaningfully by race even within that shared list: cardiac and coronary conditions were the leading underlying cause of pregnancy-related death among Black patients specifically, while mental health conditions led among Hispanic and white patients, and hemorrhage led among Asian patients — a reminder that "the four causes" aren't just where the racial gap concentrates statistically, they're conditions review committees have already concluded were preventable in the overwhelming majority of individual cases they examined.

And Then You're Dead

A national ratio like 3.5 times tells you the size of a problem without telling you where to look for it. Four specific causes, each with its own rate ratio, each pointing at a different moment in the arc from pregnancy through the year after delivery, tell you where 59 percent of it actually happened — which is a very different, and considerably more actionable, thing to know.

That's it. That's the whole thing.

Comments

Loading…

Comments are anonymous and moderated.

Sources