The Autopsy / Case File · Environmental & Climate
The Cold Doubling
The country has gotten warmer since 1999. Cold-related deaths have gotten more common anyway — more than doubling, in age-adjusted terms, and almost all of that rise happened in a single five-year stretch after 2017. The explanation researchers point to isn't the weather. It's who's outside in it, and how alone they are when it turns.
A CDC WONDER death-certificate analysis published in JAMA in December 2024 found the age-adjusted U.S. cold-related death rate rose from 0.44 per 100,000 people in 1999 to 0.92 in 2022 — a 109 percent increase — with the trend essentially flat from 1999 to 2017 before surging at a 12.1 percent annual rate from 2017 onward. CDC's own 2023 surveillance recorded 1,024 deaths attributed to excessive cold or hypothermia that year alone, concentrated in the deep-winter months. American Indian and Alaska Native people died of cold exposure at more than four times the rate of Black Americans and more than seven times the rate of white Americans in 2022, and researchers tie the broader surge to rising homelessness, social isolation, and substance use — not to colder winters.
Join the discussion →
Hypothermia and other cold-exposure deaths are recorded on U.S. death certificates using a specific set of ICD-10 codes — exposure to excessive natural cold, hypothermia, and other effects of reduced temperature — that researchers can pull directly from CDC's WONDER mortality database going back decades. That long, consistent record is what let a team from Beth Israel Deaconess Medical Center, Harvard Medical School, and Brigham and Women's Hospital build a clean national trend line, published in JAMA in December 2024, tracking exactly how the rate of these deaths has moved from 1999 through 2022 — and the shape of that trend line is the whole story. It isn't a steady climb tracking some steady demographic or climate shift. It's a flat line for eighteen years, followed by a sharp, sudden bend.
Flat for Eighteen Years, Then a Bend
From 1999 through 2017, the study found the age-adjusted cold-related death rate barely moved, rising at an annual pace of just 1.0 percent — background noise, essentially, in a rate that started at 0.44 deaths per 100,000 people. Starting in 2017, that same rate began climbing at 12.1 percent a year, more than twelve times faster, and kept climbing through the end of the study period in 2022, by which point the rate had reached 0.92 per 100,000 — expressed in the researchers' age-adjusted terms, a rise from roughly 4 per million people to roughly 9 per million. A rate more than doubling in five years, after sitting essentially flat for the eighteen years before that, is not the signature of a climate trend, which moves gradually over decades — it's the signature of something in the population's circumstances changing abruptly starting around 2017, layered on top of whatever slow climate effects exist underneath it.
Who the Rate Actually Moved For
The JAMA analysis broke the trend down by age and found the sharpest relative increases weren't concentrated only among the oldest Americans, though people 75 and older still had the highest absolute death rate of any age group by 2022, at 4.23 per 100,000. Adults 45 to 74 saw the largest annual percentage increase in the study, with their rate climbing from 0.58 to 1.54 per 100,000 — a group not typically thought of as especially cold-vulnerable, and one whose rising rate points toward circumstance (housing instability, substance use, chronic illness) more than pure physiological age-related vulnerability. Adults 25 to 44 saw their rate roughly triple, from 0.21 to 0.66 per 100,000. Children and young adults under 25 saw almost no change at all, holding steady around 0.05 to 0.06 per 100,000 across the entire 23-year period — a group largely insulated from the housing and social-circumstance risk factors driving the increase everywhere else.
The racial and regional breakdowns are sharper still. By 2022, American Indian and Alaska Native people died of cold exposure at a rate of 6.26 per 100,000 — more than four times the rate for Black Americans (1.50), more than seven times the rate for white Americans (0.88), and more than twelve times the rate for Hispanic Americans (0.51). Regionally, the Midwest carried the highest 2022 rate at 1.41 per 100,000 and the fastest regional annual increase, followed by the West at 0.94, with the Northeast lowest at 0.77. Men died of cold exposure at consistently higher rates than women across the entire study period — a pattern separately confirmed in CDC's own urban-rural mortality surveillance, which additionally found that rural death rates from excessive cold run higher than urban rates in essentially every age group, with the widest urban-rural gaps appearing among the oldest adults.
A rate that sits flat for eighteen years and then more than doubles in five isn't a story about the temperature outside. It's a story about who was left standing in it, and how much thinner the safety net underneath them had gotten.
The Explanation Isn't Colder Winters
The JAMA researchers were explicit that the surge doesn't track any corresponding acceleration in extreme winter weather severity over the same 2017-2022 window — if anything, the backdrop is a warming climate overall, with cold-related death rates rising even as average winter temperatures have not gotten more extreme by most measures. Their proposed explanation instead centers on a set of rising risk factors layered on top of whatever baseline cold-exposure risk already existed: growing rates of unsheltered homelessness, social isolation, and substance use, each of which independently increases a person's odds of prolonged, unprotected cold exposure and each of which has documented upward trends over roughly the same post-2017 window the mortality data breaks in. Homelessness researchers have separately traced a parallel rise in hypothermia deaths specifically among unhoused populations — California data covering 2021 through 2023 found that people 55 and older accounted for more than three-quarters of the state's hypothermia deaths, a population that is disproportionately living outdoors, in vehicles, or in inadequately heated housing, and disproportionately dealing with chronic health conditions that impair the body's own cold response.
Substance use compounds the mechanism directly rather than just correlating with it: alcohol and certain drugs impair the body's ability to sense cold and to shiver effectively, the body's primary defense against dropping core temperature, while also increasing risk-taking or reducing a person's capacity to seek shelter once cold exposure has begun. Social isolation adds a different kind of risk — someone living alone, with no one checking in during a cold snap or power outage, has no one to notice early symptoms of hypothermia (confusion, slurred speech, drowsiness) that a person with them would typically catch well before the point of no return. None of these three risk factors is new to public health research individually. What's new, in the JAMA data, is how sharply their combined effect shows up in the national mortality trend starting in exactly the years homelessness counts and social-isolation indicators began climbing in much of the country.
And Then You're Dead
Cold has always been able to kill a person left in it too long. What changed after 2017 wasn't the cold. It was how many more Americans had nowhere to go to get out of it, and how few people were left checking whether they'd made it inside.
That's it. That's the whole thing.
Sources
- The 109% age-adjusted cold-related death rate increase 1999–2022 (0.44 to 0.92 per 100,000), the 1999–2017 flat period (1.0% APC) vs. 2017–2022 surge (12.1% APC), age-group breakdowns, and 2022 race/ethnicity and regional rate disparities — Liu M, Patel VR, Wadhera RK, "Cold-Related Deaths in the US," JAMA, 2025;333(5):427-429, published online December 19, 2024, using CDC WONDER mortality data and ICD-10 codes X31/T68/T69
- The 1,024 excessive cold/hypothermia deaths recorded in 2023 and their concentration in winter months — "QuickStats: Percentage Distribution of Deaths Attributed to Excessive Cold or Hypothermia, by Month — United States, 2023," MMWR, CDC, February 2025
- Rural-urban disparities in cold-related death rates by age group — "QuickStats: Death Rates Attributed to Excessive Cold or Hypothermia Among Persons Aged 15 Years or Older, by Urban-Rural Status and Age Group," National Center for Health Statistics, CDC
- Hypothermia deaths among unhoused Californians, 2021–2023, and the connection between rising homelessness and cold-exposure mortality — "More People Are Homeless, and More People Are Freezing to Death," U.S. News & World Report Healthiest Communities, December 2024
- Photo: "Close Call for Homeless Tent in the Snow in Green Lake Park, Seattle," Lextrounce, CC BY-SA 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons
Comments
Loading…