The Autopsy / Case File · Chronic Disease Progression
The Attributable Fraction
Almost nobody in America is recorded as having died of obesity. The condition has an ICD-10 code, E66, and it is almost never the underlying cause on a death certificate, because the certifier is asked to name what started the chain of events — and obesity does not kill anyone directly. It kills through heart disease, through diabetes, through kidney failure, through a dozen cancers. So the number of obesity deaths in the United States is not counted. It is calculated. And the calculations disagree with each other enormously.
Four peer-reviewed attempts to estimate obesity-related deaths in the United States around the year 2000 produced numbers of roughly 112,000, 186,000, 280,000, and 365,000 — the highest and lowest separated by more than a factor of three, with one of them requiring a published correction that lowered it by 35,000 after it had already circulated as a headline. None is fraudulent. All are competent. The distance between them is a matter of which relative risks were used, which ages were included, whether smokers were separated out, and whether the model looked at a person's weight today or the highest weight they ever reached.
Join the discussion →
Start with the thing that makes this hard. When a person with a body mass index of 41 dies of a heart attack at 58, the certificate records a myocardial infarction, probably with coronary atherosclerosis on the line below it, and possibly type 2 diabetes and hypertension in Part II. The National Center for Health Statistics defines the underlying cause as the disease or injury that initiated the train of morbid events leading directly to death, and it is that single condition — the one at the bottom of Part I — that becomes the cause in every national mortality statistic. Obesity, in that framework, is upstream of the chain rather than in it. It is a reason the chain existed at all.
Why the Certificate Can't Answer It
This is not an accident of paperwork; it is what the instrument is designed to do. Part I asks the certifier to write the sequence: the immediate cause on line (a), then each antecedent condition below it, with the underlying cause lowest. Part II is reserved for other significant conditions contributing to death but not resulting in the underlying cause. A physician who believes obesity is the reason a patient is dead has one place to put that belief, Part II, and no obligation to use it. Most do not. Obesity has consequently never appeared on any list of the country's leading causes of death — not because it doesn't kill people, but because the counting system was never built to see risk factors, only diseases.
So the field does something else. It uses a population attributable fraction: take the relative risk of death associated with a given body mass index category, estimated from a cohort study; take the share of the population in that category, estimated from a survey with measured heights and weights; combine them to get the proportion of deaths that would not have occurred if everyone in the high-risk category had the mortality risk of the reference category; multiply by total deaths. The arithmetic is simple. Every input is contestable.
Four Numbers for the Same Year
In 1999, Allison and colleagues published in JAMA the first rigorous national estimate, drawing hazard ratios from five prospective cohorts — Alameda, Framingham, Tecumseh, the American Cancer Society's Cancer Prevention Study I, and the NHANES I follow-up study — plus published results from the Nurses' Health Study, and applying them to 1991 body mass index distributions. Their mean estimate was 280,184 obesity-attributable deaths annually, range 236,111 to 341,153. Restricting the hazard ratios to nonsmokers and never-smokers and applying those to the whole population raised it to 324,940. That is the origin of the "about 300,000 deaths a year" figure that became standard in public health argument for a decade.
In 2004, Mokdad and colleagues at CDC published "Actual Causes of Death in the United States, 2000," which reframed mortality around modifiable behaviors rather than diseases. Tobacco led at 435,000 deaths, 18.1 percent of all US deaths. Poor diet and physical inactivity came second, originally published as 400,000 and projected to overtake tobacco; JAMA issued a correction in January 2005 revising it to 365,000, or 15.2 percent. Note what the category is: diet and inactivity, the behaviors, not obesity, the physiological state. The two get quoted interchangeably and are not the same quantity — one is a behavioral exposure, the other an outcome of it.
Then in April 2005, Flegal, Graubard, Williamson and Gail — working at CDC's own National Center for Health Statistics — published a directly competing estimate in the same journal. They pooled relative risks from NHANES I, II and III with mortality follow-up, applied them to the BMI distribution measured in NHANES 1999–2002, and adjusted for age, sex, race, smoking and alcohol. Their answer for obesity, meaning a BMI of 30 or above: 111,909 excess deaths, with a confidence interval running from 53,754 to 170,064 — roughly a third of Allison's number, produced inside the same agency that had just published the 400,000 figure. Two further findings were more disruptive still: overweight, a BMI between 25 and 30, was associated with 86,094 fewer deaths than normal weight rather than more, and underweight with 33,746 excess deaths of its own.
The disagreement is not about whether obesity kills people. It is about which epidemiological convention you accept, and each convention moves the answer by six figures.
The Weight-Loss Problem
The most consequential methodological objection is not about statistics at all. It is about who ends up in the "normal weight" box. Almost every one of these estimates classifies people by their weight at a single moment — the day they were surveyed. That group therefore contains two very different populations mixed together: people who have always been at a normal weight, and people who were formerly obese and have since lost weight. Some of that weight loss is deliberate and healthy. A great deal of it is the weight loss that accompanies cancer, heart failure, COPD, and the last years of life. Stokes and Preston, writing in PNAS in 2016, used NHANES data from 1988 through 2010 linked to death records through 2011 to compare models built on weight at survey against models built on a person's maximum attained weight. The maximum-weight models performed substantially better, and the reason was exactly this: mortality among people who had lost weight was exceptionally high, and folding them into the normal-weight reference category makes normal weight look more dangerous and obesity look less dangerous than either is. Their conclusion was that studies based on body mass index at survey — which is most of them — have consistently underestimated the effect of excess weight on US mortality.
Two years later, Preston, Vierboom and Stokes applied the maximum-BMI approach to the question of why American mortality had stopped improving. Introducing maximum lifetime BMI into a Cox model controlling for age and sex raised the annual rate of mortality decline by 0.54 percent, with a confidence interval of 0.45 to 0.64 percent. In plain terms: without the rise in body weight between 1988 and 2011, American mortality would have been falling meaningfully faster than it did. They estimated that the increase in maximum BMI over that period reduced life expectancy at age 40 by 0.9 years as of 2011, and accounted for 186,000 excess deaths in that single year.
What Age Does to the Answer
The other major fault line is age. Most deaths occur in old age, so an attributable-fraction estimate is extremely sensitive to whatever relative risk it assumes for older adults — and the cohorts that supply relative risks tend to underrepresent them, or exclude the sickest of them to control for reverse causation. Masters and colleagues, in the American Journal of Public Health in 2013, used nineteen waves of the National Health Interview Survey linked to individual National Death Index records from 1986 through 2006, modeling both the age variation in obesity's mortality effect and the cohort variation in how long people had been obese. They found a substantially stronger association at older ages than earlier work, and an attributable share rising across successive birth cohorts: 15.6 percent of adult deaths for white men and 5.0 percent for Black men, 21.7 percent for white women and 26.8 percent for Black women. Those are proportions, not counts, and they sit far above what a 112,000-death estimate implies against roughly 2.4 million annual American deaths.
A parallel approach skips attributable fractions entirely and reads the certificates in bulk, using every cause listed rather than only the underlying one. Adair and Lopez, in BMC Medicine in 2020, defined obesity-related cardiovascular mortality as any cardiovascular disease appearing anywhere on the certificate alongside diabetes, chronic kidney disease, obesity, lipidemias or hypertensive heart disease. On that definition, half of all US cardiovascular multiple-cause mortality qualifies, against 40 percent in Australia — and the rate was rising about 3 percent a year, fastest at the youngest ages.
What Follows From Picking One
None of this is academic housekeeping. The choice of estimate determines whether obesity is described as the second-leading preventable cause of death in America or as a problem an order of magnitude smaller than tobacco. It determines how a cost-effectiveness model values a bariatric procedure or a GLP-1 prescription, which prevention programs get funded, and how large a benefit a regulator may claim. And it sets the background against which current prevalence is read: NCHS put adult obesity at 40.3 percent during August 2021 through August 2023 and severe obesity at 9.4 percent, the latter up from 7.7 percent a decade earlier even as overall obesity held roughly flat. Whatever the per-death multiplier turns out to be, it is being applied to two in five American adults.
And Then You're Dead
The certificate will say heart disease. It will be accurate. Somewhere behind it is a number nobody can produce without first choosing a method, and the honest range of that number spans a quarter of a million deaths a year. This is what an uncounted cause of death looks like from the inside: not a cover-up, not a mystery, just a question the recording system was never designed to be asked, answered instead by models that agree on the direction and not the size.
That's it. That's the whole thing.
Sources
- The definition of underlying cause of death ("the disease or injury which initiated the train of morbid events leading directly to death"), the Part I chain-of-causation structure with the underlying cause lowest in the sequence, and Part II as the place for other significant conditions contributing to death but not resulting in the underlying cause — National Center for Health Statistics, "Instructions for Classification of Underlying and Multiple Causes of Death," NVSS Instruction Manual Part 2a, Section I, 2021
- The 280,184 mean annual obesity-attributable deaths (range 236,111–341,153), the 324,940 estimate derived from nonsmoker and never-smoker hazard ratios (range 262,541–383,410), and the six data sources used — Allison DB, Fontaine KR, Manson JE, Stevens J, VanItallie TB, "Annual Deaths Attributable to Obesity in the United States," JAMA, October 27, 1999, 282(16):1530–1538
- Tobacco at 435,000 deaths (18.1% of US deaths) and poor diet and physical inactivity at 365,000 (15.2%) for the year 2000, the latter corrected downward from the originally published 400,000 — Mokdad AH, Marks JS, Stroup DF, Gerberding JL, "Actual Causes of Death in the United States, 2000," JAMA, March 10, 2004, 291(10):1238–1245, with erratum published in JAMA, January 19, 2005, 293(3):293–294 and 293(3):298
- The 111,909 excess deaths associated with obesity (95% CI 53,754–170,064), the −86,094 figure for overweight (95% CI −161,223 to −10,966), the 33,746 excess deaths associated with underweight (95% CI 15,726–51,766), and the method of applying NHANES I, II and III relative risks to the NHANES 1999–2002 BMI distribution — Flegal KM, Graubard BI, Williamson DF, Gail MH, "Excess Deaths Associated With Underweight, Overweight, and Obesity," JAMA, April 20, 2005, 293(15):1861–1867
- The finding that maximum-attained-weight models outperform weight-at-survey models, that mortality is exceptionally high among people who have lost weight, and that studies using BMI at survey have consistently underestimated obesity's mortality effect — Stokes A, Preston SH, "Revealing the Burden of Obesity Using Weight Histories," Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, January 19, 2016, 113(3):572–577, using NHANES 1988–2010 linked to death records through 2011
- The 0.54 percentage-point increase in the annual rate of mortality decline when maximum BMI is controlled for (95% CI 0.45–0.64), the 0.9-year reduction in life expectancy at age 40 in 2011 (95% CI 0.7–1.1), and the 186,000 excess deaths attributed to rising maximum BMI in that year — Preston SH, Vierboom YC, Stokes A, "The Role of Obesity in Exceptionally Slow US Mortality Improvement," Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, January 30, 2018, 115(5):957–961
- The estimated share of adult deaths between 1986 and 2006 associated with overweight and obesity — 5.0% and 15.6% for Black and white men, 26.8% and 21.7% for Black and white women — and the finding of a stronger obesity–mortality association at older ages and rising attributable shares across birth cohorts — Masters RK, Reither EN, Powers DA, Yang YC, Burger AE, Link BG, "The Impact of Obesity on US Mortality Levels: The Importance of Age and Cohort Factors in Population Estimates," American Journal of Public Health, October 2013, 103(10):1895–1901, using 19 National Health Interview Survey waves linked to National Death Index records
- The multiple-cause-of-death approach and the finding that diabetes-, kidney-, obesity-, lipidemia- and hypertensive-heart-disease-linked cardiovascular deaths comprise 50% of US and 40% of Australian cardiovascular multiple-cause mortality, rising about 3% per annum — Adair T, Lopez AD, "The Role of Overweight and Obesity in Adverse Cardiovascular Disease Mortality Trends: An Analysis of Multiple Cause of Death Data From Australia and the USA," BMC Medicine, August 4, 2020, 18:199
- Adult obesity prevalence of 40.3% and severe obesity prevalence of 9.4% during August 2021–August 2023, and the increase in severe obesity from 7.7% in 2013–2014 — National Center for Health Statistics, "Obesity and Severe Obesity Prevalence in Adults: United States, August 2021–August 2023," NCHS Data Brief No. 508, September 2024, using NHANES
- Photo: NHANES program director Clifford Johnson and USDA Food Surveys Research Group leader Alanna Moshfegh reviewing "What We Eat in America" dietary intake data, U.S. Department of Agriculture photo by Peggy Greb, public domain, via Wikimedia Commons
Comments
Loading…