And Then You're Dead

The Autopsy / Case File · Vehicular & Transit

Not Built to Track

A pedestrian killed by a car generates a clean, standardized federal record within the same system that has tracked American traffic deaths for half a century. A pedestrian, or a rider, killed by an e-scooter generates something closer to a shrug — a category the country's main crash-death database was never built to hold, so nobody actually has to.

The National Transportation Safety Board, after reviewing news reports, NHTSA and CPSC records, and a road-safety research center's data, identified at least 119 e-bike and e-scooter deaths in the U.S. between 2017 and 2021 — and concluded, in a formal December 2022 report, that the number is very likely an undercount, because none of the federal systems built to catch fatal crashes were designed with these vehicles in mind.

And Then You're Dead · September 2026 · 10 min read

Join the discussion →
A cluster of black dockless electric scooters parked together on a sidewalk at a street corner, with parked cars and buildings in the background
Shared dockless e-scooters parked on a San Jose sidewalk. Federal crash-reporting systems built for cars and motorcycles have no clean category for the vehicles that now sit on street corners in nearly every American city. Photo: Grendelkhan, CC BY-SA 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons.

E-bikes and e-scooters went from a novelty to street furniture in the space of about five years. Dockless scooter-sharing companies launched in dozens of U.S. cities starting in 2017; e-bike sales, boosted by pandemic-era commuting shifts and a wave of state and local purchase incentives, climbed into the millions of units annually within a few years after. The infrastructure to count how people are dying on them did not keep pace, and the reason isn't bureaucratic neglect so much as a structural mismatch: America's core traffic-fatality tracking systems were built, field by field, around a small set of vehicle categories — car, truck, motorcycle, bicycle, pedestrian — that predate the entire micromobility category by decades, and retrofitting a new vehicle type into that structure has turned out to be slower than the vehicles themselves spread.

Where a Death Actually Gets Filed

NHTSA's Fatality Analysis Reporting System, FARS, is the backbone of American traffic-death statistics — the source for nearly every widely cited number on how many people die in motor vehicle crashes each year. But FARS has a specific, hard eligibility rule: a fatality qualifies only if it involves a "motor vehicle in transport" on a public roadway. An e-scooter, legally classified in most jurisdictions closer to a "personal conveyance" — the same catch-all category that includes wheelchairs and children's toy wagons — often doesn't meet that bar on its own, particularly in a single-vehicle crash with no car involved. Fatalities that do get logged frequently land folded into the pedestrian category rather than getting a vehicle-type code of their own, which means an e-scooter death and a person struck while walking can be functionally indistinguishable in the same dataset. E-bikes fare somewhat better on paper: NHTSA reclassified them in 2022 away from a moped-adjacent code into the same category as ordinary, non-motorized bicycles — but that reclassification means a fatal e-bike crash is now grouped statistically with a $200 kids' bike from a big-box store, erasing exactly the distinction (motor-assisted speed, added weight, different crash dynamics) that makes e-bike safety worth studying as its own question in the first place.

0
e-bike and e-scooter deaths NTSB identified nationwide, 2017–2021, via news reports and agency records
0
year NTSB formally called for standardized federal micromobility death and injury data collection

Built From News Clippings, Not a Database

The 119-death figure itself is a tell. The NTSB didn't pull it from a single authoritative government count, because no such count exists — it assembled the number by cross-referencing news media reports against whatever fragments NHTSA, the Consumer Product Safety Commission, and an academic road-safety research center could separately supply, then reconciling the overlaps. That's the same basic methodology a newsroom or an advocacy group would use, applied by the nation's premier transportation-safety investigative agency, because the alternative — a purpose-built federal micromobility fatality database — simply doesn't exist. The NTSB's own December 2022 safety report was explicit that this was a problem, not a finding to be reassured by: it identified "a lack of standardized, as well as a dearth of complete and reliable data on e-scooter and e-bike fatalities and injuries" as a central obstacle to understanding the risk at all, and recommended that NHTSA, CPSC, and the Federal Highway Administration coordinate on consistent tracking — including adding specific e-bike and e-scooter product codes to national injury-surveillance systems that, as of the report's writing, had no clean way to distinguish them from other categories.

The number came from cross-referencing news coverage against scattered agency fragments — the same method a newsroom would use, run by the federal government's own transportation-safety investigators, because no purpose-built count exists.

What CPSC's Side of the Data Shows

The Consumer Product Safety Commission's own injury-surveillance system, NEISS, offers a partial and separately limited window into the same problem, because it captures product-related injuries treated in a representative sample of hospital emergency departments rather than a comprehensive fatality count. CPSC's tracking has documented a rising trend in e-bike- and e-scooter-related injuries and deaths over the past several years, concentrated disproportionately in a mechanism NHTSA's roadway-focused systems are especially poorly equipped to catch: lithium-ion battery fires. A battery failure that starts a fire in an apartment, a garage, or while charging overnight is not a traffic crash in any sense FARS was built to record, and a resulting death gets classified, if at all, as a structure fire fatality — filed under fire-department and local medical examiner records with no obvious link back to the e-bike that started it, unless an investigator specifically makes that connection and codes it that way. It's a second, entirely separate blind spot layered on top of the roadway-classification problem: not just uncertain data on crash deaths, but a fire-death category growing in parallel that most fatality statistics don't connect to micromobility at all.

A Regulatory Structure Still Catching Up

The practical consequence of this data gap isn't abstract. NHTSA's proposed pedestrian-protection and vehicle-safety rulemakings, state-level e-bike classification laws (most states now use a three-tier speed-and-power system modeled on a template several bike-industry and safety groups helped develop), and municipal scooter-share permitting programs are all being written and revised without a reliable national picture of how, exactly, people are dying on these vehicles — whether it's predominantly motor-vehicle collisions, single-vehicle falls, battery fires, or some other mechanism entirely, and whether risk concentrates among riders, pedestrians they strike, or both. Some individual cities and university-affiliated road-safety research centers have built their own local tracking to fill the gap for the jurisdictions they cover, and NHTSA has taken incremental steps — the 2022 e-bike reclassification among them — toward better categorization. But the core recommendation from the NTSB's 2022 report, that federal agencies build genuinely standardized, coordinated micromobility fatality tracking, remained substantially unimplemented as of the most recent public accounting, which means the next NTSB-style tally, whenever it comes, is likely to be assembled the same way the last one was: by hand, from the news.

What the Clinical Literature Fills In

Where federal crash statistics fall short, peer-reviewed trauma and emergency-medicine research has stepped in to describe at least part of the risk picture, even without a national fatality database to anchor it to. Trauma-registry studies of seriously injured e-scooter riders have repeatedly found helmet use in the single digits — one major-trauma-service analysis recorded helmets on roughly 6 percent of injured riders, compared with 45 percent of injured cyclists and 76 percent of injured motorcyclists at the same facilities, a gap researchers attribute partly to scooters being marketed and used as a spontaneous, no-preparation-needed way to cover a short distance rather than a planned ride someone would gear up for. Alcohol shows up as a recurring factor in emergency-department studies of e-scooter injuries at rates as high as 30 to 43 percent of cases, concentrated heavily in nighttime incidents, and riders under the influence were found in one study to land on their head or face in 84 percent of falls, against 58 percent for e-scooter crashes generally. None of this clinical literature substitutes for the national death count NHTSA and CPSC still don't reliably produce, but it does describe, in granular hospital-level detail, the mechanism the federal gap leaves unquantified at scale: an unhelmeted rider, disproportionately at night, disproportionately after drinking, on a vehicle capable of 15 to 20 miles an hour with none of the protective structure a car or even a standard bicycle frame provides.

And Then You're Dead

A car crash generates a federal case file within days. An e-scooter death, on a sidewalk two blocks away, might generate a local news story, a police report filed under a category built for something else, and nothing that connects it to the 118 other people who died the same way that year. The vehicles caught on. The counting didn't.

That's it. That's the whole thing.

Comments

Loading…

Comments are anonymous and moderated.

Sources